Name: Emily_Anne (Signed) · Date: 07/30/08 15:49 · For: Discussions

Wow... I sortakinda get it... but then wouldn't Harry die the same time as Dumbledore?

Name: nesit721 (Signed) · Date: 11/02/07 3:24 · For: Discussions

That was...very interesting...i think it would be really good if you wrote a sequel.

Name: nesit721 (Signed) · Date: 11/02/07 3:22 · For: Discussions

That was...very interesting...i think it would be really good if you wrote a sequel.

Name: yordaman (Signed) · Date: 06/11/07 11:03 · For: Discussions

That was funny that Hermione kept saying Voldamort to annoy Ron. Write more Its really good!

Name: hpobsessed (Signed) · Date: 11/13/06 16:39 · For: Discussions

That is some interesting speculation. It is just that JKR has denied all rumors of Harry or Ron being Dumbledore... excelently written though. Very in character.

~N~

Name: Hip_Hop_Muggle (Anonymous) · Date: 07/03/06 12:13 · For: Discussions

Wow! I never thought of it that way! That was my little brother's theory for a while and I just ignored him but now...
Great story! 10/10

Name: Hip_Hop_Muggle (Anonymous) · Date: 07/03/06 12:09 · For: Discussions

Wow! I never thought of it that way! That was my little brother's theory for a while and I just ignored him but now...
Great story! 10/10

Name: tonks_lupin_shipper (Anonymous) · Date: 06/15/06 15:27 · For: Discussions

WOW!!! This makes perfect sense! I really wouldn't be surprised if this really is the case.

Name: Choggstar (Signed) · Date: 05/27/06 16:22 · For: Discussions

An interesting story, but it's more like a strung together mix of theories really. A bit of doctor who, Harry Potter and mixed identity all thrown in together. I've heard a theory like this before, I can't say I believe it though. Dumbledore withdraws Dumbledore's memories from his own head, you could explain this off with some technicality but it's all just way too complex and not satisfying enough to be a real answer.
You get the character's behaviour just right though, and there are so many fan fictions where they change the character completely.

Also, HEY! You're from England as well, I didn't know how many Brits there were on this site! .

Name: samiseriouslyam (Signed) · Date: 04/11/06 8:45 · For: Discussions

? That WAS confusing. But it made some sense. (I think...)10/10

Name: LilyPotter (Signed) · Date: 02/27/05 11:39 · For: Discussions

Very interesting veiw of things! I agree with doggstarr, It fits perfectly into canon! That would also be a wonderful plot twist for the books, although I'm not sure if J.K thought of it. She prolly thought of somthing brilliant anyway :-) I rate this a 10 for your good idea and wonderful explanation!

Name: RedHeadMama (Signed) · Date: 02/26/05 19:13 · For: Discussions

Very intreting theory, it could fit i suppose but i just don't see it as very likely in JKR's world. Thanks for trying to spell it out though

Name: doggstarr (Signed) · Date: 02/08/05 13:18 · For: Discussions

What an incredible idea and it fits so perfectly into canon. Your a genius mate.

Name: hollyana (Signed) · Date: 12/31/04 7:49 · For: Discussions

Nice idea! Really original as well. I like the way you seem to have explained every avenue of thought and evidence in the books and it means that Harry Potter can continue forever! *Yay!* (Well for a 150 odd years anyway!) I don't know whether you thought of this or anything but you could link Dumbledore's alchemy work with Nicholas Flamel with Snape's teachings of Harry possibly? I don't know whether you're a Snape fan or not, just a suggestion! Nice work. : )

Name: Collie Jenkins (Signed) · Date: 12/09/04 13:37 · For: Discussions

Er....WOW! I never thought of that in a million years! That is the most...fantastic and yet unpredictable but entirely and completely believable!! And you never told me before Jenny?!?! I don't believe you! It's just....well, amazing...*awestruck*