Login
MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!

[Report This]


Stories by SeaIsleWitch [11]
Favorite Authors [8]
Favorite Stories [17]
SeaIsleWitch's Favorites [25]
Reviews by SeaIsleWitch


by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/01/05 Title: None

A wedding! Most excellent!

Author's Response: *wink*



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/01/05 Title: None

But we like roses and lollipops as much as scarey darkness......I like the vows!

Author's Response: I had to resist the urge to go "super cheesy sweet", because it just wasn't Snape! I am glad that you liked the vows!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/02/05 Title: None

Oh......cliffhangers! Please update soon...I need my Ellie/Snape fix! 10/10 as usual!

Author's Response: This story should be updated in no time, depending on how busy the queue is. You rock, SeaIsleWitch!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 05/04/05 Title: None

I was delighted to see this update! The saga continues and now we have a new mystery: What's in the black velvet box? (Who but Lucius would give a little boy such a gift?) I like the way you write Julian; his baby words are very cute. Well done!

Author's Response: Hello! Glad to hear from you! I modeled Julian's speech after my best friend's daughter. I hope to update at both sites very, very soon!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 04/12/05 Title: None

Have you abandoned this story? I hope not! I need to know what happens to our flawed heroine!!!

Author's Response: NO, I have not abandoned this story. I have just been very ill.



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/06/05 Title: None

Well, Sev did tell Ellie to go to Malfoy if something happened to him. It's his own *#* fault! Snape will just have to see the logic of her crazed actions (huh?) and get over it! Love isn't easy, especially theirs, so they will just have to make their way back to each other in this latest trial. Wonderful job weaving your tale! Can't wait for more!

Author's Response: It is a mess, you know. I think Ellie was hasty and Snape needs to forgive. We shall see................



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/01/05 Title: None

That was really, well, sweet.....I like your character Ellie very much. I'm surprised to see that I am accepting the fact that (in your story) Snape and Malfoy aren't so bad......at this time at least.....I will read on.....

Author's Response: I am very pleased that you like Ellie! As per Snape, I think you will find that, even though he is total jerk to Harry and the other students, Snape is not so bad. Severus Snape is my favorite HP character. Malfoy...er, he is bad, plain and simple; however, in my story his character is questionable. Thank you for your feedback!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/02/05 Title: None

Oh.....even two damaged people such as Ellie and Severus understand that sleeping with Malfoy (esp. when pregnant) is WRONG on so many levels....I guess the lollipops and roses are over???? I must read on.........(Great job, by the way! Hard to believe it's the first thing you've written since an English paper! I'm working on my first, but it is slow going and not nearly clever enough......)

Author's Response: Oh yes, it is VERY wrong, on so many levels. Would you believe that I was actually angry with myself for writing this plot line into the story? Well, I was. The storyline demanded to be written and I could not ignore it.

Many thanks to you, SeaIsleWitch! Writing fiction is very different from writing research papers or essays, but yes, this was my very first "creative" writing attempt ever.

My advice to you is this:
1) take it slow, fanfiction is not going to disappear over night.
2) get a Beta! I did not have a beta for this story and it made it 3 times as difficult. I now have a wonderful Beta who is working with me on my other stories. (I still don't have one for this story!)
3)Don't get discouraged if people don't like your story immediately, but do listen to reviewers who have something constructive to say.
4) HAVE FUN!!! We don't get paid for this! It can be great fun!



Highly Improbable by Vocalion

Rated: 1st-2nd Years •
Summary: COMPLETE. A woman visits Hogwarts expressly to meet Severus Snape. Her eccentric aunt led her to believe that he was the kindest, handsomest man to ever grace the earth. What will she do when she discovers the awful truth - let a few minor imperfections stand in the way of romance? Highly Improbable has been recognized by the Multifaceted Awards as Winner in the Laughter Category and Runner-Up in the Identity Category (Best Original Character), and also by MNFF's first annual Quicksilver Quills Awards. Thanks, MuggleNet!
.

Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/03/05 Title: Chapter 25: Believe It, Beloved

"a jagged toenail gouged an ankle"... my favorite line! Cleverly funny, again!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 01/31/05 Title: Chapter 12: The Bumpy Road to Love

Succulent raisins! Hysterical! Best chapter yet......can't stop laughing!

Author's Response: Laughter is the reaction I always hope for. Thanks!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 01/31/05 Title: Chapter 14: Almost Like Being in Love

Huh??????????? Time travel via the hedge?......mmmmmmm.........I will read on.................or is it a dream sequence????



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 04/26/05 Title: Chapter 30: The Jarvey Jive

BRILLIANT!!! I was laughing hysterically from the first paragraphs on... I didn't see how you could top the pair's last excursion, but you did it! The Jarvey, Glutgut, was so much more than I expected...he was clever, funny, rude, and even a bit snugly! What an interesting past he has! LOL! I can't stop thinking about Snape and Glutgut in matching kilts! What possibilities! I'm ready for the next chapter! (Vocalion, thank you for choosing Glutgut as the Jarvey's name! I'm thrilled!)

Author's Response: I'm glad you liked it. I think Glutgut expresses his personality very well. Thank you for reviewing and for suggesting the perfect name!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 01/31/05 Title: Chapter 16: Let's Call the Whole Thing Off!

You should have named her Ella.......



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 04/11/05 Title: Chapter 29: Taking a Chance on Love

(Finally able to review!) …”Winning her respect is the most important thing in the world to me – next to receiving the Order of Merlin. And, the best part of all, Snape realized with a satisfied smile, I didn’t even have to give her the ring! I can have my Cauldron Cake and eat it too!”….. Oh no he can’t! I was blown away by this chapter! When I wasn’t laughing, I was holding my breath in anticipation! Oh you do weave your spell so eloquently! The banter between Minerva and Dumbledore was classic. I loved the magic carpet scene – from Snape sprawled awkwardly underneath it to Snape majestically commanding it while he stands on it! Oh, how I look forward to every chapter! Again, congratulations of the well deserved “Featured Story” nod and I will submit my Kneazle name very soon!

Author's Response: Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter and relieved that I can finally respond to reviews again!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 03/01/05 Title: Chapter 27: Full Moon and Empty Arms

Amazing, again! Snapes' nightmare was absolutely hysterical! Just when I thought Lupin was going to bite her and Snape couldn't save her - it became even worse --- for Snape! Lupin was now the hero! Brilliant! (Foreshadowing the night to come also.) The whole chapter was just "spot-on"! (My new favorite saying!) By the way....I've decoded the anagram......clever girl....

Author's Response: Congratulations, and thanks for not giving it away! Snape won't be solving it for a few more chapters yet. Thanks for reviewing!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 04/11/05 Title: Chapter 29: Taking a Chance on Love

Did I write Kneazle? I did mean Jarvey. I like (L Loony's) the suggestion of Limerick - a rude Jarvey who talks in awful limericks!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 03/21/05 Title: Chapter 28: Everything Happens to Me

Outstanding! I laughed so much! He's such a Snape! I think I know what Dumbledore gave Snape and I will absolute love it if it is what I think it is - oh the possibilities! (I'm using one in my own story - but quite different circumstances.) You write Snape so well, I can't tell you how much I enjoy reading this story! Well done! Spot on!!!!!

Author's Response: You are so sweet to review every chapter! Not many reviewers do that! Yes, I'm sure it's what you think it is. And, no, I won't be going for the obvious song title to name the next chapter. :-D Thank you for your many kind reviews.



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 01/31/05 Title: Chapter 21: I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm

Berlin may have wrote it, but only Ella could sing it. Great chapter......I will read on....

Author's Response: She's my favorite singer. I often put her CD's on in the background while I'm writing my chapters.



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/16/05 Title: Chapter 1: Prologue: Witch In Exile

No, your story is NOT sappy!



Reviewer: SeaIsleWitch Signed
Date: 02/16/05 Title: Chapter 26: There'll Be Some Changes Made

Only my feable attempt is sappy!

Author's Response: To the contrary, I enjoyed your chapter synposis immensely! I'm glad you found your way to Occlumency, where the big girls play! :-D