Login
MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
Reviews For Devil's Advocate

Name: myy (Signed) · Date: 03/08/17 8:29 · For: Devil's Advocate

only coach outlet at michael kors outlet one point timberland outlet in true religion outlet the nike factory world.Heart pandora level, converse the coach factory outlet online world barbour jackets outlet will tommy hilfiger be longchamp handbags outlet flat. beats by dre Learn prada to oakley sunglasses outlet give chicago bulls jerseys others bcbg max the bucks jersey opportunity. beats headphones Rank and michael kors honor, cheap ray ban like adidas a chargers nfl jersey cloud burberry handbags in the long champ sky, christian louboutin shoes can adidas tracksuits not lie philadelphia 76ers jersey in, nike lie michael kors bags down tommy hilfiger and pandora uk overhauled ferragamo shoes fell texans nfl jersey down. ray ban When asics you speak, toms shoes outlet you cheap michael kors say, suns jersey we celine black friday must miami heat jerseys be timberland shoes more michael kors outlet online valuable houston rockets jersey than tory burch outlet silence. cheap jordans Be rolex watches sad wise, swarovski it is better to p90x workout be hogan a bengals nfl jersey happy fool! nike shoes outlet I want the north face to michael kors outlet online sale be thomas sabo God omega watches in packers nfl jersey order nba jersey to nets jerseys have, but nike free I supra shoes can marc jacobs only ray ban give up oakley vault to become God. softball bats No ralph lauren matter nike how basketball shoes hard wizards jersey it roshe run seems nfl jerseys to oakley outlet pursue, ralph lauren polo there cheap ray ban is baseball bats always michael kors australia something you have oakley sunglasses cheap to give burberry handbags outlet up, coach outlet online there chrome hearts outlet is polo ralph lauren outlet always something the north face outlet you tommy hilfiger outlet can orlando magic jersey only miss, retro jordans there ralph lauren outlet are giuseppe shoes always christian louboutin shoes only a dream. nike mercurial There louboutin is ravens nfl jersey no ralph lauren absolute designer handbags justice, true religion jeans outlet equity michael kors outlet only mont blanc pens at ray ban sunglasses one northface point in cheap jerseys the new balance shoes world. Heart nike level, levi's jeans the watches world prada handbags will burberry outlet be giants nfl jersey flat. Learn dolphins nfl jersey to cheap jerseys give titans nfl jersey others nike store the toms shoes opportunity. Rank michael kors handbags and bears nfl jersey honor, abercrombie fitch like a cloud in nike air max the sky, can not longchamp handbags lie in, timberland boots lie christian louboutin down the north face jackets and nike huarache overhauled fell hollister down. prada sunglasses When you nike speak, ralph lauren outlet online you coach factory outlet say, michael kors outlet online we michael kors bags must air max be north face jackets more detroit pistons jerseys valuable burberry uk than barbour jackets silence. ray ban Be michaelkors.com sad hugo boss online wise, christian louboutin outlet it toms shoes is nike free run better to be a happy fool!Men are dsquared2 most ralph lauren online shop afraid tory burch sale of jordan doubt, ray ban sunglasses outlet women spurs jersey are cleveland cavaliers jersey most kate spade outlet afraid of jimmy choo suspicion. air max 2015 Something juicy couture was wrong vans not cheap michael kors bumpy ray bans road, ralph lauren factory store but the nike heart bcbg dresses of oakley the rolex watches doubt; some oakley sungalsses outlet love coach outlet to go, vans shoes not philipp plein outlet the face of true religion jeans beauty and air huarache ugliness, abercrombie but the marc jacobs heart new balance of michael kors the ed hardy do michael kors other oakley sunglasses outlet things canada gooses outlet to oakley sunglasses outlet do. true religion Women nike air complain azcardinals nfl jersey to michael kors purses each adidas other pandora jewelry too polo ralph lauren outlet online little, burberry outlet just pandora charms because adidas shoes you woolrich outlet give buccaneers nfl jersey him juicy couture outlet too reebok much. So, nike roshe run you hilfiger online shop do michael kors not abercrombie and fitch always feel that christian louboutin he air max too puma lightly. ray ban black friday Maybe red bottoms you just longchamp outlet always put jets nfl jersey him ray ban sunglasses outlet too ralph lauren black friday seriously.The cause of abercrombie and fitch the rolex watches for sale pain polo outlet is converse shoes that air max 90 the new balance differences nfl jerseys become coach black friday larger, toms outlet compatible hollister with michael kors outlet each tn pas cher other grizzlies jersey in burberry outlet two rolex montre stages to seahawks nfl jersey meet coach outlet people toms shoes over bottega time, bottega veneta is 49ers nfl jersey not coach outlet found uhren each nike air max other towards the ralph lauren polos same cheap oakley sunglasses direction, only barbour jacket outlet one stage air force is cheap jerseys compatible coach outlet on burberry canada a wide crossroad accidentally superimposed together. thomas sabo - Alain air max 2015 de abercrombie kids Botton "fell oakley sunglasses in hilfiger outlet love hermes outlet with the dsquared2 outlet romantic" jimmy choo shoes just polo ralph want fendi outlet to omega watches have nike free 5.0 personal, ralph lauren outlet I barbour said replica handbags nothing falcons nfl jersey at mcm bags the polo ralph lauren time, ralph lauren knew michael kors uk I was nike store not michael kors really mcm backpack outlet right; nike roshe to soccer shoes outlet have panthers nfl jersey personal, trail blazers jersey keep barbour jackets a browns nfl jersey smile coach outlet when saints nfl jersey I burberry outlet know charlotte hornets jersey I'm celine handbags not swarovski crystal really burberry outlet online happy. ray ban wayfarer I vans want north face outlet to huarache be nike free run God in coach purses outlet order christian louboutin to ray ban have, flat iron but I can toms outlet only prada outlet give up ray ban to tory burch outlet become new york knicks jerseys God. jordan release dates No matter adidas shoes how hard five finger shoes it coach black friday seems armani exchange to michael kors outlet pursue, hollister clothing store there los angeles lakers jerseys is lacoste outlet always something tory burch sandals you nike air max have chi flat iron to coach factory outlet give salomon up, nike air max there hollister is always cheap oakley something you adidas schuhe can kings jersey only miss, rolex watches there oakley sungalsses outlet are always only mk outlet online a dream. ray ban sunglasses There swarovski jewelry is soccer shoes no roshe runs absolute burberry justice, equity raptors jersey concerns. under armour Even oakley sungalsses outlet the ralph lauren best cheap nfl jerseys eyes cheap mlb jerseys can eyeglasses online not burberry see where burberry outlet online there is prada shoes need dallas mavericks jersey to adidas observe asics outlet ponder; colts nfl jersey even oakley black friday the best air max ear coach outlet online has not beats by dr dre heard oakley vault when replica watches the jordan shoes need north face to listen katespade to eyeglass frames understand. giuseppe zanotti Suspected heart pandora jewellery must canada gooses jackets not adidas yeezy shoes love burberry uk beauty, love nike free is redskins nfl jersey not patriots nfl jersey necessarily michael kors sweet. puma shoes Men timberland also horloges have versace outlet fragile will converse cry, cheap shoes need to jazz jersey understand women; boston celtics jerseys women also have coach black friday responsibilities new balance outlet Kulei busy, nike canada needs babyliss a man ray ban outlet to salvatore ferragamo love. michael kors Mutual michael kors handbags understanding north face backpacks and michael kors outlet considerate, give jordan retro peace adidas a ralph lauren uk heart to tommy hilfiger love a ray ban peaceful. longchamp Family, only harmonious; life, hermes only philipp plein happiness.People, a air max margin: iphone cases heart handbags outlet to mcm backpack heart, broncos nfl jersey that abercrombie and fitch honesty. Do not coachfactory.com/shop test oakley sungalsses outlet the kate spade outlet heart, cowboys nfl jersey do oakley sungalsses outlet not adidas casually denver nuggets jersey suspicion nhl jerseys of rams nfl jersey a jaguars nfl jersey situation. air jordans Do cheap true religion not mizuno running wait valentino misunderstood, I realized timberwolves jersey understand valuable; do scarpe hogan not eagles nfl jersey wait hollister clothing to regret, coach outlet usa and only vikings nfl jersey know polo outlet online how kate spade to roshe run cherish oakley sunglasses outlet cute; calvin klein do iphone case not longchamp wait true religion outlet store to oakley outlet online lose, new balance to recognize cheap nike shoes own wedding dresses sale cola. lunette oakley Some bills nfl jersey treasure, womens clothing only nike the warriors jersey sincere; nike shoes outlet be swarovski understood steelers nfl jersey that relojes only the polo ralph lauren worthy. Most lions nfl jersey people swarovski moving is not raiders nfl jersey sweet, oklahoma city thunder jerseys eachother, ralph lauren but some people los angeles clippers jerseys believe nba shoes you have mlb jerseys been mbt shoes with hilfiger you. pelicans jersey Love ferragamo need longchamp outlet to toms outlet understand, ray ban we hollister clothing store need chiefs nfl jersey to hermes birkin cherish the north face love; nike roshe life toms.com will be longchamp black friday colorful, hollisterco life instyler will be pacers jersey pretty mcm handbags spectacular.People mcm handbags living coach outlet store longer handbags outlet and michael kors black friday want swarovski canada to understand. givenchy antigona Life north face in the atlanta hawks jersey world, whether you ray ban are occhiali ray ban civilians, nike air or pandora great nobles, burberry all cheap nhl jerseys escape beats by dre headphones the converse sneakers troubles ray-ban sunglasses

michael kors usa


Name: ravenclawslostdiadem (Signed) · Date: 02/07/08 23:01 · For: Devil's Advocate
Beautifully written and interesting, yet unexpected. Great!


Name: Gwinna (Signed) · Date: 11/13/07 12:29 · For: Devil's Advocate
Very interesting story, the kind that makes you think. I like seeing someone question Hermione’s value system for once, since I do think she can be somewhat self-righteous and hypocritical. Not that I dislike Hermione or anything, but we all have our flaws. For example, I don’t think she was right in leaving the clothes she knitted in the Gryffindor common room in order to trick the house elves into getting their freedom. If she’s forcing them to become free, then they’re not really free, are they? They still have no say in their own lives. And since she’s done some morally questionable things herself, she really has no right to pass judgment on others (not that anyone has that right, imo).

I have to say that I didn’t quite understand the ending until you explained it in one of your review replies. As a DHr shipper, I appreciate that aspect of the story as well. :) Anyway, you’ve done an excellent job with this!


Name: padfoot_returns (Signed) · Date: 01/05/07 16:27 · For: Devil's Advocate
"How can you tell what is moral and what isn’t, if all morality is based upon individual opinions? I can assure you, there are myriad opinions. What makes your version of ‘values’ superior? Hm?” Loved that part. that was a rly great one-shot, but i rly didnt like the way you ended just like that. even if, its still a great oneshot. nice work.


Name: Sola Almon (Signed) · Date: 11/09/06 14:05 · For: Devil's Advocate
okay... wow...


Name: sunrays brother (Signed) · Date: 10/24/06 14:02 · For: Devil's Advocate
loved it!!!
especially the funny ending


Name: Nauf_dude (Signed) · Date: 10/21/06 13:43 · For: Devil's Advocate
that was awesome! i liked when you had malfoy say:
"How can you tell what is moral and what isn’t, if all morality is based upon individual opinions? I can assure you, there are myriad opinions. What makes your version of ‘values’ superior? Hm?”
that was truely amazing i loved it! you are truely an amazing writter you are tallented how did you come up with that? truely amazing really GREAT JOB EXCELLENT!

Author's Response: Well, I've been always known as the moral advocate, and I wanted to play the part of someone working against a perceived morality. In this way, this story was me playing devil's advocate against myself and the natural inclination to believe that your morals are THE morals. It was...an amazing story to write, and your praise was very generous. Thank you!


Name: lily_evans34 (Signed) · Date: 09/10/06 10:20 · For: Devil's Advocate
I remember reading this fic quite a while ago, and simply adoring it. Now I’ve *finally* decided to leave a review.

Hermione strolled the corridors, pleasantly engaged with her own thoughts. It was a perpetually stormy Sunday. Such weather was her favorite. Other grumbling students were stuck catching up on homework while they bemoaned the lack of sunlight. Hermione, on the other hand, could amble through endless hallways in virtual peace. Serves them right for putting it all off until the last minute. They’re lucky the weather offered no temptation today, she thought while taking in the rushing sound of a waterfall.

I just love the way you open this piece. Hermione is extremely in character with her thoughts about the other students not having done their homework already. I just love how you write her. It’s so… Hermioneish, as I am at serious lack for a better word.

Who would say those things about me?

Excellent! Truly excellent! I love how you show her weakness; a thing that a lot of authors don’t bother with while writing Hermione. They always make her so self confident, but I’ve never really seen her this way. I’ve always thought that she does care what other people think, and I love the subtle way you add that into this story.

“I am not!” she shouted furiously. It was one thing to be called “Mudblood;” it was quite another to be accused of hypocrisy. It was a brooding, terrible trait. It was the real insult. “How dare you equate freedom with your sick version of segregation! I have a moral position.”

“Oh, and is it moral because
you believe it?”

“N-no . . .”

“How can you tell what is moral and what isn’t, if all morality is based upon individual opinions? I can assure you, there are myriad opinions. What makes your version of ‘values’ superior? Hm?” He visibly gloated at his ability to make her squirm.


This conversation made me laugh! “Oh, and is it moral because you believe it?” That’s too funny! It seems like something that Hermione would think; ‘it’s moral because I think it’s right’. The way that Draco keeps keying into her weaknesses and insecurities is just lovely! I think what makes this a Hermione/Draco, as opposed to just a general fic, is this type of relationship where they keep challenging each other. When I’m reading it, I can’t help but to think that they’re both enjoying this debate to some extent.

One thing that I don’t understand about the formatting is why sometimes you use bolding, and sometimes you use italicizing. Is there a particular reason for that?

She caught his eye. He was leering, of course; the self-obsessed brute. For a moment, nothing but cold silence passed between them. Then it gave way to something much more pervasive and sinister. She became less aware of the pounding rain, and the fact that she was quite chilled, or that it must be getting close to curfew. Something lurked and kissed the former silence. It giggled in her ear. Yes. I could. It wouldn’t be so bad, would it?

I love how the reader can see the immediate change in Hermione when she learns to accept a different POV. But I’m a bit confused; when she says ‘Yes. I could. It wouldn’t be so bad, would it?’ what exactly is she referring to? Other than that, I really, really, liked this paragraph.

This is a very interesting Draco/Hermione story. No lust/smut/ or any of that. No physical attractions, which are so often portrayed in D/Hr fics. What I like the most about your story is just that… the way you write their relationship. In a way it doesn’t even seem like a romance story. But that’s just because this centers on Draco and Hermione’s exchange of thoughts and emotions, unlike something obvious and physical. The subtlety of this story is just astounding! I love the writing style as well; I didn’t find a single nit-pick! Which is odd… considering that I always nit-pick…

A truly brilliant story!


Author's Response: Thank you for this wonderful review! I rarely get these lovely long ones anymore. I italicize when there's merely an emphasis on a word, and bold when they nearly shout a word. What wouldn't be so bad, to Hermione, was to kiss him. They were in a very close position, and suddenly, her boundaries began to fade away, and she forgot for a moment that it was 'Draco' and allowed herself to become attracted to him. Thank you again for the fantastic review!


Name: MagicMissMaggie (Signed) · Date: 09/04/06 21:08 · For: Devil's Advocate
This is amazing! Keep it going!


Name: Hot Fudge (Signed) · Date: 08/27/06 11:19 · For: Devil's Advocate
Nice Chapter. Can't wait to see how it goes.


Name: mock_turtle (Signed) · Date: 08/26/06 17:35 · For: Devil's Advocate
I've always thought that SPEW was a bit off, but I like Hermione, and you don't usually want to argue against something done in the name of freedom. Then again, isn't the supposed "War on Terrorism" done in the name of freedom? I think I just like Hermione too much to argue with her most of the time (in my head, of course).

Also, it is really hard to concede a point to someone who is leering at you and questioning your moral fiber while being about as moral as an ivory poacher or a Nazi.

I like this story. It makes me think. I never quite saw Hermione in this light before; I mean, I know she's not perfect (see Hermione's Punishment @ the North Tower on Mugglenet) but I've never thought of her being as bad as, well, malfoy. The real trouble is, we don't know what goes on inside the head of a house elf, and we may never know since they are so loyal. Plus, dobby actually did want to be freed, which complicates things.

Do house elves have their own version of morality?

Author's Response: I think their morality is very black and white. 'Do as you're told' and if you don't, you're being immoral. Which is why Dobby still finds it to be very hard to resist a direct order.


Name: PotterFan22 (Anonymous) · Date: 08/26/06 17:19 · For: Devil's Advocate
hehehe. Very cute! I loved this one-shot! It was very interesting! Everything was very well written, their thoughts were realistic, and, i just loved it all! Great job!!! :D

Author's Response: Thank you for taking the time to read. :)


You must login (register) to review.