Login
MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
TheVanishingAct [Contact]
06/17/05






[Report This]


Stories by TheVanishingAct [3]
Favorite Authors [0]
Favorite Stories [18]
TheVanishingAct's Favorites [18]
Reviews by TheVanishingAct


by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 12/04/05 Title: None

You know I love you and your story here, and not just because I particularly have fallen for McKee or the fact that I approve of her man, Bill. It's the fact that you are so talented with words. Your phrases paint a vivid image by only using a few words, and that's so important to the story line. It is fast and gripping, and you don't bore us with long, unnessacary details. That's why I love you. You can do so much with so little. And did I mention your dialogue? It matches the characters so well! You know them so well, it makes your fic outstanding. Some examples of your fine writing:

First off, your lovely imagery. "Her robes were the darkest hue of blue, and tiny flecks of gold seemed to blink in and out of existence between the folds." That gives some excellent images in the mind's eye. One of my favorite descriptions I have ever read. "The other professors were lined at her sides, as if holding the lines before a war. Each face held it’s own emotion locked within, with no eye sockets to see out of." They are serious, aren't they? It just gives that sense that yes, something is wrong, and something is about to happen. "There were clouds of a most peculiar color – like that of mud, churning as if it were water absorbed into cotton." Ew. Sort of like when a tornado is about to strike, I imagine? Gives that feeling of even more immediate danger.

But oh no, the suspense didn't stop there. "Something had happened." I kind of figured this out, but it still builds on top of my boiling anxiety. And then, without warning, out it comes: "Finally, her thin lips opened to reveal something entirely mundane. “Headmaster Dumbledore will take a night’s rest this evening. I will be taking his place in all matters. Please continue on with your meal.”" I didn't get it- that couldn't be what happened! But, later of course, we know what happenend. Dumbledore isn't resting normally, so to speak. ANd the cliffhanger. Oh woe.

Lastly, we simply must talk about McKee. She has simply swept me off my feet once more, and I have dived into fanfiction world to ask for her hand in marraige. Kidding, but still, she's one of my favorite OC's of all time. You know her so well, and I know her so well, it's as if Rowling put her in the series herself. Examples of her replies that make her so wonderful: "“I don’t think you need to be slaughtering me with those eyeballs. I got it for you, didn’t I?”" and the even more funnier "“Might have helped to tell me that before, wouldn’t it?”". Truly, truly great. Clasic material. :)

And proof McKee can have and make friends! I was so happy seeing this theme crop up, such as in following excerpts: "“Not now! Be like you later! Right now, I need a friend!”", courtesy of Ginny. It's so sweet. "“You got one word,” McKee quipped." Aw! She's trying to be a friend now! I knew she had it in her. "“The Muggles are going to kill You-Know-Who?” someone snorted derisively at the back. McKee noted to make friends with whoever said that." Not only was this hilarious and so much like McKee- she considered making a friend! Wow! McKee has grown so much. I could go on and on about her character growth, but we'll save that for another time, as I'm afraid I'm rambling on too much.

To conclude, you are an excellent writer, and I appreciate the fabulous fic you have presented us with. Please, keep up the good (no no, great) work, otherwise, I might die. ;)



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 12/11/05 Title: None

What? Where are those reviews that you are so deserving of? Either they are very invisible too everyone (or just me), or they have been stuck into cyberspace. Well, I hope this is neither of the two, as I bestow it on you with the upmost care. Let me just go ahead and tell you that there will be lots of fanboy love and gooey Bill/McKee shipping in this review. Tread carefully, or you might be sucked into it all. But, I suppose any author would love that so- off we go!

I think the first thing that I'm going to start off with is the absolute amazing character development that you have installed in with your romance epic adventure... thingy. *cough* McKee seems to be a whole new person at one point, when suddenly she comes back to her old self! I've read several romance fics where they either refuse to make their characters grow or the plot development is squish. However, not only did you install the world of Harry Potter in this (as you should, this being a fanfiction site) with the fact that Harry and Voldemort do have the face off and the threat is growing immensley, but you put a romance into it. I love love LOVE you for doing that. *ahem* Just a few things that show how McKee's both grown and stayed the same: " Didn’t she used to care less for the students than for furry rocks by the water? Now, though, she couldn’t stand the idea of such a loss." MKee realized those students were important in her life. Brings that tear out of the corner of your eye that you never realized you would use! "“Oh, no dear, please don’t cry-“~~~“-I’m not-”" Of course. McKee still doesn't want anyone that she cares or loves or any of that jazz. Still her old self. Very comforting to see. " While her face wasn’t visible, McKee was assured of her safety when a snore emitted from the twisted covers." Not much to say here except that she still judges actions as away to comfirm something, and not words.

And you score once more with the wonderful, vivid imagery you set before your readers. It gives the sense of magic that performing a spell or concocting a potion could never supply. A few examples that I won't even bother to comment on, as they are fabulous by themselves: "The sky was splashed with hues of violets and pinks, contrasting sharply with heavenly bright green grasses swaying with each breath of wind.":--:"Any book she wanted to read would appear at the slightest whim; she wanted for nothing. Hunger did not strike her belly and thirst did not dry her tongue.":---:"On clear night, she would stand at the edge of her hill and see only blackness below and a broad, shining tapestry of sparkling stars laid out like a feast above her."Just inserting her that this is my idea of heaven, and that it should be "On a clearnight,""Some mirages were hoaxes created by dark wizards to inflict pain on a weak mind."They laughed and giggled by the flickering lights and the twinkling of stars glimmering on the polished floor. “I’m getting married, Poppy, to that girl there!” Such a great scene there.

Now, other lines that weren't particularly imagery but very nice line nonetheless: "A grazing eyeful to her left showed a long row of medical cots lined up against the wall." Nice little idea of what the hospital wing is like at the time. "Some, she presumed were filled with bodies despite the curtains curled around them for privacy." This is nasty, but would be very common at a time like this. "Professor Lupin was lying back with his eyes open. He sported deep gashes in his abdomen. So profusely were they bleeding that his dressings and sheets had to be changed very soon." This makes the reader assume Lupin shall die. Some might not be to happy with this. "There was a Ravenclaw girl McKee didn’t know very well. She looked to be reading quite calmly, utterly unaware of the bulbous sore on the top of her head." Ravenclaw. Reading. I get it! ;) "Oh bother. He was jesting. Quite obviously, her nightmares about Bill had come back to haunt her in the form of bad jokes." That was really funny! You even added some humor!

For my last paragraph before I wrap the review up, I am having Bill/McKee issues- issues that involve too much squeeing when Bill was not dead, and he and McKee are going to marry. It made me so very happy, that I think I accidentally laughed when Pomfrey and Bill started dancing. You worded that scene so well.

Well, I guess what I am saying is that I am very happy that you are winding this up to a fabulous ending, yet sad the story is ending. Keep up the good work in the future, and you'll go very far.



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 06/29/05 Title: None

"This hallway is so stupid, he thought. Stupid like Potter." My favorite line!! Fabulous work.

Author's Response: Hey, thanks for reviewing! I love that line too. :D



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 07/23/05 Title: None

Hey Tif! I just read it, and I must say wow! You pinned all of the characters completely, and planted an excellant storyline as well. The flashback was great as well, and it took me by surprise- I usually hate flashbacks. Only one spelling error, homophone usage thing- but other than that, it was great. -10-

Author's Response: Thanks! I'm glad you liked it! = )



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 07/28/05 Title: None

Okay, to start out with, some good things. Ginny was completely in character, and the dialogue in the present was believable as well. The plot stayed right on topic, and it flowed very nicely which provided a nice read. On the other hand, I do think that in the flashback Ron and Harry were a tad OOC for getting into a physical fight. Although they do get mad at each other and won't speak (example: GoF), they are best mates, and they wouldn't fight. However, besides a usage error in the dialogue, it was quite a nice read and I look foward to more.

Author's Response: I know that I was walking a veery fine line with the fight between Ron and Harry, but I re wrote that part several times and had several betas look over it for me, and every one said it was in order. I know its not likely to happen in the books, but I needed it there for my purposes. = )



Excerpts from Nagini's Diary by Scheherazade

Rated: 1st-2nd Years •
Summary: A look into the life of Voldy's pet snake, Nagini.
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 08/14/05 Title: Chapter 1: Memiors of a snake...

I feel the need to give you a review. I hope that second chappie gets up soon! ;-) I love the last entry though... it was all I could do to stay in my desk chair from laughing so hard (okay maybe not that much but still it was pretty funny) -10-

Author's Response: Me too! Glad you liked it and laughed so hard! :-D



Promises to Keep by Gemmika

Rated: Professors •
Summary: It's been six years since Harry and Ginny have come face to face. Different career oprions led them in different paths than they had hoped but now at the wedding of Ron and Hermione they are forced back together. Will their fragile love survive the troubles that haunt their pasts? Rated "R" for Sexual scenes, Teen Pregnancy and Spousal Abuse in this story.
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 09/04/05 Title: Chapter 2: Just a Kiss

Okay... now, for the good things. I happened to quite like the story; the plot has me drawn to read more, and that's very hard to do. I also happened to like that you used Ginny like she was meant to be used (to me at least); somewhat defying what she knows and wants something more. I also liked your background; it makes for a very interesting read. ~/~/~ However, I did notice some things to improve upon. The dialogue is either very choppy, or is otherwise too long. Replacing those commas and putting them in other areas would help tremendously. I also believe that Harry is a bit too outraged at times. This causes him to seem OOC, when in general, he isn't.~/~/~With that said, I do think that it is really good, and I suggest you keep the plot building from here.

Author's Response: Thanks Patrick! I'll make sure to use your suggestions. Perhaps you'd like to help me beta read? Contact me by PM!



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 09/04/05 Title: None

Okay, I don't often say this, but: I'm in love with your story. I like the fact that you gave Lily and her views of how Petunia transformed from her loving self into the Petunia we know and love. The only mistake I saw was that their was a "Petunia's" as a "Petunias". Aside from that fact, it is good, and I see great chapters coming.



Sorting Hat Songs by the nutty imp

Rated: 1st-2nd Years •
Summary: A collection of Sorting Hat Songs that I wrote.
To writers, feel free to use it for your fics.
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 07/28/05 Title: Chapter 4: Sorting Hat Song 4

Alright, this was really good, and I think that it will help a lot of people. I do see the sorting hat singing this in canon, even though it's not. I also like the descriptions you used for the four founders, and it seemed very much like I would see them. The only thing that really threw me off is when you used "fellows" and "yellow" for Hufflepuff. Although it does rhyme without the 's', it makes the poem a little more choppy. All in all, a good piece.

Author's Response: You're right. I'll try and correct that one. ^_^ thanks.



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 07/27/05 Title: None

Very nice, I liked it quite a bit. I think you used just the right intensity, which is really good, and I also loved Luna in this fic. The flow was a bit choppy, but really, you did a great job. -10-



Curse of the Reapers by deanine

Rated: 3rd-5th Years • Past Featured Story
Summary: A different sort of alternate universe... It is a world under the thumb of an ancient emperor. Muggle society has been oppressed beyond recognition. Wizards rule over all, their only laws defined by power. This is the story of a rebellion, a family, a traitor, and the long road that leads home at last.
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 12/03/05 Title: Chapter 1: Prologue

Bridget, you are awesome. AU is certainly not a dirty word. Whoever thought it could be was slapped upside the face with your fic. I won't even go too far into detail with how awesome you've made your prologue, I'll just cover the basics. First off, that beginning was amazing- the Seer idea just made everything a bit more ideal for the amazing setting you described. Spero's prophecy makes a head reel at what possibly could be the seven. I cannot wait to find out.

Turpin is very, very evil- you made me invision the setting, the aura of horror in the room, the demeanor only a villian could have- it was absolutely fantastic. I enjoyed seeing him in my head.

And the last part of the prologue? Oh my! You took my interest and made it skyrocket. I must keep reading, I must, for my curiosity's sake.



Author's Response: Yay! Thanks so much for the kind words. I'm glad you liked Turpin and Spero. They slip off the canvas for twenty chapters or so, but it's good to know they left an impression. :)



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 12/03/05 Title: Chapter 2: A Rebel at Heart

I must echo what my fellow spewer down there has said, that I won't be giving a SPEW worthy review until the last chapter I come across today. I am glad that you started off with an explanation of part of the society. It gives so much depth to the story that you could swear it was published and on the shelf of the nearest bookstore. It really seperates itself from the usual AU to the not-so-normal AU. And I much prefer the latter now, since you make it so convincing.

I remember someone saying that it is "brilliance", and I must agree. From the first line "Surrounded on all sides by a sea of sand, the Tower of Erudio rose above the land of Ortus.", you must pay rapt attention as so not to miss a single detail. A mark of an amazing fic.

Some high points of your chapter, when Albus is waiting, thinking. It really was fabulous to read, and Sirius description. Quite well done! The fact that James and Lily aren't having the baby (yet, I should hope), and the introduction of the Reapers, for which you had so graciously deemed the name of your fic for.

Off to the next chapter- I simply cannot put this down.



Author's Response: :D You are entirely too kind. I think this is a conspiracy to swell my head so that it won't fit through the door.

Sincerely, the kind reviews have been a pleasant surprise. :) :)



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 12/03/05 Title: Chapter 3: Orientation

Now, Harry, Ron, and Hermione have been introduced. I am wondering what those plot complications further on in the fic shall be as to have Ginny destroyed. (Not that I mind too much. Over it right about... now.) Although I do miss Bill and Percy.

I do love the little quote above the chapter about the society that the rebellion was against. You really have created a whole other world, and applaud you- it is amazing.



Author's Response: Ginny doesn't get to be a Weasley. But I begin to believe that she will be in the fic. Like Ginny, Percy gets to wander across the canvas with the Weasley surname. :) Thanks for the kind review, dear.



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 01/24/06 Title: Chapter 14: Acceptable Measures

Bridget! Oi, with so much, I haven't reviewed yet. Makes me very sad. I just want to let you know that this chapter is absolutely wonderful. *sighs happily* It is love. So much love, it won't fit inside the earth's core. *huggles*

Author's Response: Thank you Pat. :) *hug*



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 12/03/05 Title: Chapter 4: I Spy With My Little Eye

"My name is Tom Riddle."

*stares* *continues to stare* *blinks*

Okay then... I loved the letter from Albus to Remus, so simplistic, and so much like that man. It was another great read- especially Severus in his state. Exactly how I imagine him. I also love how you describe the school in the eyes of the kids. You are doing a marvelous job.



Author's Response: My name is Tom Riddle... Everyone just loves that line? :) :) Glad you're still enjoying it Pat :)



Sins of the Father by TheVault

Rated: Professors •
Summary: There was something about him that made him irresistible to her. Siobhan Murphy will go to any lengths to ascertain her deepest desires - but when the object of those desires is a married man twice her age with secrets darker than she can imagine, she will find herself caught in a scandalous liaison that she can't walk away from. Not Canon-Compliant.
Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 03/30/07 Title: Chapter 19: Chapter 19: In Want of a Distraction

I think this is my favorite chapter yet, dear. :) I especially like Siobhan's wit. She's just fantastic, I don't know how many times I can say that. It just shows up constantly. I love the Pansy-Siobhan exchange. I nearly died laughing at that. *sniggers when looking back at it* Oh, I chose an instant gratification review, btw, Hope you're happy with that. :D I might come back and leave a better review later, though. :D Jenna, fantastic as usual. It's great, you're great, you're writing is great, Siobhan is great... So much greatness.



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 02/19/07 Title: Chapter 18: Chapter 18: Wounded

Dear, dear Jenna. How I have missed reviewing for thee. I’ve been reading Sins since my last review which was chapter what - 15? 14? 16? Somewhere around there. And even though that’s not many chapters without a review from me skipped, I still feel unfaithful to Sins. It’s simply unfair how much control you have over me using Siobhan and her story. Now I feel the need to review every chapter I missed in order to make it up to Siobhan. Dang it. I’ll have a guilty feeling everywhere I go. *sigh* Enough blubber. Time to get to the meat.


Now, me being the First Mate of HMS Tiramisu and the dedicated shipper I am, I was very pleased to see that Siobhan is in the throes of despair over Lucius. Their relationship kept the story going, and it kept revealing a darker side to what once was a lust-filled free-for-all. Now that it’s all been thrown in the open and the smut has been wiped clean, what do we have to keep us tied to the story besides your fantastic writing and our dedication to Siobhan? Surprise! The Lucius/Siobhan dynamic! While we are getting snippets of Harry/Siobhan from unexpected sources [which, hopefully, will continue. >.>], the Lucius/Siobhan relationship spirals into its climax. I say this because - while the side plots are anything but romance, the focus is the relationship. I look forward to what you have in store next.


I looked for nitpicks everywhere - and unfortunately for my review - there was none found without me being such a picky person that it would seem incredibly unfair to point it out. So, you’re off the hook. ;)


I do have something I would like to bring up with you: Miss Pansy Parkinson. You can handle her character so well. She’s nasty, she’s feisty, she’s a downright b*tch. You made it so marvelously clear that she wants to bed Draco, and that she hates Siobhan for thinking she did just that. Oh, how I wanted to slap her. You’ve heard this many times before from me, but I get such a connection with your characterization that it is absolutely unreal. ““Filthy,” Pansy sneered. “That’s what you are. A filthy little slag.” Pansy’s insults are so… imaginative. XD We know Pansy isn’t the brightest bulb in the box - who in their right mind would like Draco? - but she’s not afraid to get filthy with her words. Scandalous, my dear. XD


Siobhan. How I love thee and your dialogue. “I’d like to know why you’re entitled to an explanation.” I love it when there is dialogue between Siobhan and someone else because it’s always an interesting affair, and it keeps me very much entertained. I just thought I might as well go ahead and throw that in there. She’s the epitome of awesome.


You know I love Sins just as much as I love Tiramisu. It’s got everything you need in a story - action, betrayal, discovery, smut. I’m just leaving another fan boy review. Please excuse me. [And this is shorter than my typical review because - well - the chapter is shorter than normal ;)]



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 11/19/05 Title: Chapter 7: Chapter 7: Tiramisu

And I stake my claim as first mate of Tiramisu, a Siobhan/Lucius ship- all becuase of the wonderful situations you have here. It is an amazing piece that hooked me in for once and for all, and I'm afraid that I might go crazy for more chapters in the upcoming weeks. You make the reader want Siobhan to kill Narcissa, kick Draco in the- you know, and have Lucius all to herself. And her mistakes relationship wise make you all the ready to shake some sense into her for her foolishness. In other words, you want Siobhan to succeed. And win Lucius from Narcissa's grasps (for the rest of your fandom to rip to shreds).

Just to show you an example of how you do that: Starting with: “I imagine I’d enjoy them all, Mr Malfoy,” Siobhan replied, almost mimicking his tone. “I’m sure whatever you choose will be suitable.”. Siobhan seems so naive and not herself at the moment. You question a bit on what she's doing, but following that: “Was that me taking your breath away, Mr Malfoy?” Siobhan asked slyly, her back up against the wall of the kitchen." And we see her again! Man, Siobhan rocks. But wait- there's more! His breath caressed her neck and when he spoke it was in a low whisper that would have gone unheard were his lips not touching her ear. “Have you ever been with a man, Miss Murphy?” You know, after this rollercoaster with Siobhan, I was expecting to just have a smile put on my face with that statement. But oh no, you made it so I has to squee with excitement. It was coming! "This time, Siobhan could not help but tremble. Still, she tried to retain the control of her voice, as difficult as he was making it." Once more, reinforcing that something's ahead. “How is that any of your business, Mr Malfoy?” she asked as briskly as she could manage." It's right around the corner! You could cut the tension with a knife. It makes it all the more exciting.

“Would your wife approve of your curiosities?”Ugh! Siobhan ruined it for herself with this statement! You just want to slap some sense into her before she really screws it up. “How can I know you’re not playing a game with me?” Too late. Siobhan was so close, she could have had Lucius right then and there, but she just had to say the wrong things and- "All her thoughts were chased away as Lucius brushed his lips against hers for one infinitesimal moment." You tricked us? After I went through the trouble of being worried for my favorite ship's future, and then you make it so Lucius is turned on by her words! “Well then, Mr Malfoy,” she breathed. “The tiramisu will be fine.” I bet Siobhan thinks something else is fine as well.

Now, I could only see two things that need to be changed (or should be, mind). First off, you have "cozy" as "cosy". Secondly, when you say "She followed the small servant out of the drawing room and towards the dining hall; off to the side was a door Siobhan had noticed before, and it was through there they went." This tripped me up as I was reading it. I think that what really makes it such a danger is the latter half of the sentence. I would recommend changing it somehow.

Now, for a few more things before I wrap my review up. Robison Crusoe is in a wizard's house; pureblood for that matter. And the Malfoys. Why? It really picques one's interest. Also, this: He left her as she was, slamming the doors behind him, proving that it wasn’t out of consideration that he had let her be." made me a tad curious and left me thinking rude things towards Draco and his dramatic and nothing-like-Lucius ways. "When she awoke the first rays of dawn were shining through a large window at one end of the library, and she had a pain in her lower back from sleeping in a less than comfortable position." I know what that feel like- not nice at all, and definately real in the way you worded it. The pain is very bad (for lack of a better word), and you described it really well. She handed it to her husband, along with a kiss on the cheek and a look that told Siobhan exactly where Lucius had been and what he had been doing. ... I think this one is self-explanatory.

Oops, one more point before I actually stop writing. You bash Narcissa and Draco to no end in your fic. And please don't stop, as I love it very much. Especially what I like to call the "Cissy moments". An example: "Siobhan made sure to make the process long and problematic, so as to rile the filthy woman as much as possible." I love it. I also would like to note Narcissa and Lucius have a very odd relationship, and I'd like to know more why Narcissa and Lucius act this way (although I have a pretty good guees).

Now, I'm actually winding down! It was excellent, as for the rest of your fic, and I simply cannot wait for the next installment, otherwise I might go crazy. And we can't have that now, can we? ;)



Author's Response: It's nice to have a fan that's not a crazed woman :D Nice demographics you're providing me with ;)

Thank you for pointing out that sentence, I actually don't like it myself. I'll have to edit it. And 'cosy' is a British spelling.

*quickly keeps writing so Pat doesn't go crazy*



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 08/07/09 Title: Chapter 25: Chapter 25: Choices

So the other day when I went to bookmark the stories I meant to review, I also went to bookmark the reviews that I had already completed. I came to bookmark Sins, and I got angry because I couldn’t find my review for Chapter 25 anywhere. It wasn’t until I realized that I reviewed A Sudden Movement and not Sins that I came back to my senses. *ahem* So, not only does your story cause mass hysteria and rejoicing in my soul every time there’s a new chapter posted, it causes senior moments as well. That’s wielding some mighty power there, dear. ;)

Alright, for the actual review, I’ll just start with the plot. Guh. You’re becoming notorious for these plot twists! First, in the last chapter, Siobhan gets the “offer” to be engaged to Draco, and now Siobhan gets this proposition to marry Draco for appearances’ sake and be Lucius’… erm, sex slave. And she says no! And she argues with her mother! And she takes off into the middle of the night towards Scandinavia to be a pig farmer or Lord knows what! This has been one of the best recent chapters in terms of plot development. The Lucius-Siobhan sparring is practically a staple high point now, but the sparring between Siobhan and her mother was a good change of pace, and it fleshed out not only Siobhan, but her mother as well. To see her plan to marry Siobhan off to Greer is unthinkable, yet her own mother would do it just because he was the best alternative. That heartless bitch! Siobhan was clearly hurt by her mother’s almost-actions as well. That’s one of your strong points, dear: emotion. It channels through your writing in such an impeccably clear manner that it’s almost impossible for the audience to ignore it. I say that it’s almost impossible because there are those out there who can’t appreciate a good moment of literature when they see it, but with the clarity of your writing, they should certainly be few and far between.

In a deadly silence, the door clicked shut behind Siobhan. This is one of my favorite lines out of the entire chapter. I’m not entirely sure why. Maybe it’s because it frames the following scene incredibly well: Lucius, calm yet nervous, a deadly predator, wants Siobhan to agree to his plan, yet she remains an incredible adversary that won’t bow down to his will any longer. It’s powerful and elegant at the same time, much like Lucius. It’s not about Lucius any longer, though; it’s Siobhan and her future that’s at stake, and she’s the one who makes the silence deadly. It speaks absolute volumes.

'What exactly does your plan entail?' she asked slowly, making sure to communicate with her tone that her guard was not down yet. I adore Siobhan, not just for how much she’s grown as a character in recent chapters, but because she’s done it despite the assumptions of her character. She’s a true Slytherin, one who can be cold, self-preservative, and (shown in this bit) calculating, and despite all of those factors that many allow to block growth for Slytherin characters, she grows with these traits because you’ve allowed her to. She’s not allowing Lucius full control anymore, and she, for one of the first times, has grabbed the reigns of her life. I also want to mention, pertaining to the self-preservativeness of her character, that she’s running away to save herself. It’s either being married to Draco or Greer, and she can’t choose; neither option is one she finds desirable (or really, any decent person would), and she’d rather run away from her fears rather than face them, a true self-preservative instinct that Slytherins are known for. I think the instinct is called fight or flight, and it’s been hinted all along that she’s capable of both. However, when the situation called for an either/or instead of another way out, she dives into her first instinct, giving us a greater look into her character. Brilliant, Jenna. :)

'If you wish to refuse my offer, I will personally withdraw the proposal from Shannon. But, before you make a decision, discover your mother's true intentions for you. I don't believe you're fully aware of what she had planned before I presented her with a more desirable alternative." To take a quick nitpick, you usually use a single quotation mark to… well, mark dialogue. Here, though, you’ve got a double one at the end. *goes into further tirade about the essence of the quotation mark and the debate on using one mark or two, and how that it’s necessary to use only one or the other to form consistency*

>.>

I do want to talk about that bit of dialogue from Lucius, though, because it is another look into the mind of his character. It’s rather… conflicting, if you will. On one hand, I agree with Siobhan that Lucius would never intend to hurt her, and that he’s doing this out of her best interest, in a sort of “I’m-saving-you-from-a-worse-alternative” sort of way. However, on the other hand, I must admit that it seems a little selfish for him to mention this, in maybe the hopes that after having her (rather exciting and saddening) conversation with her mother, she’ll flock to him to avoid having to marry Greer. It’s just another example of how you consistently make him both yin and yang; he’s looking out for himself and for her. I think it’ll take an act of completely selfless love for Siobhan to finally believe in him (and for everyone reading, as well).

I love the conversation with Siobhan and her mother, but I think I especially love the fact that it enforces Sibohan’s decision to choose flight over fight. Genius!

To close this review, I’ll end with my second favorite line from this chapter: She looked around her room again. It no longer seemed empty. Now it seemed to teem with naivety and innocence. Despite its elegance, it seemed like a child's room, full of a child's playthings. It was a place that needed to be left behind. I think what’s so striking about this moment in the chapter is, for one, your lines are never lines but that they’re moments which is incredible in and of itself, but for two that it also reinforces my idea that Siobhan has grown up and that she’s ready to look out for herself, and not just for her and Lucius’ relationship.

And yes, this was written extraordinarily well, but I tell you that every single time I leave you a review, and I think you’ve heard it enough. :P



Reviewer: TheVanishingAct Signed
Date: 10/14/06 Title: Chapter 15: Chapter 15: Secrets Revealed

*gulps* Well, I had planned on re-reading this since it's been such a long time since I read it initially, and I didn't even read the beta'd version. So I merrily come to MNFF after a nice cup of hot chocolate and prepare myself to read and review this. I just... I cannot believe how much better each chapter gets. When you get a new one, it's as if it's better than the last -- and nothing can ever beat it. For instance, chapter seven is brilliant, and the kiss is sinful itself, but what happens in chapter eight is so much more gratifying than chapter seven. I believe chapter fifteen is the best chapter so far, because not only does the characterization gain miles more depth, but the verbal battles continue to get bigger and better, and possibly more dangerous. The writing continues to get better, and -- best of all -- more of the plot is revealed inch by inch. I am before the creator, I am not worthy. *bows* ;)


I'm going to go ahead and fit in some crit before I continue onwards, because I will likely forget about it while I'm raving about everything. First off: “You know, I do love that smile of yours,” Lucius murmured hungrily While I absolutely love the line [Siobhan/Lucius is love], it does not make it exempt from having a period at the end. ;) Also, this line needs one too: “Perhaps you should open it,” Lucius remarked, and Siobhan noted that he hid his impatience admirably, though she knew him well enough to not be fooled


However, the short weekend passed as most enjoyable times do, and quite soon, Siobhan found herself sitting in History of Magic on a Monday morning with a complete lack of ability to care about the unimportant, monotonous drones of the incorporeal Professor Binns. I absolutely live this line, because you captured everything about a dreary, boring school day due to your descriptions. Everyone that I know hates Monday mornings, and we all know Professor Binns is someone we'd rather never have a class with. I love Siobhan during this whole scene -- especially when she and Harry get in a little verbal battle of their own. *sniggers* Oh, and this line: “Don’t ask questions you know the answers to, Potter,” Siobhan replied tediously. “It makes you seem like an idiot.” seems to echo a certain line that a certain someone you have taught us to love... is she perhaps learning something from Lucius through their affectionate banter? *sighs* Gorgeous.


“Look — I’m well able to look after myself,” she insisted. “I know you’ve got that hero complex bit going on, and that’s lovely, it really is — but I don’t need saving.” *dies laughing* "hero complex"? *rolls on the floor* One reason I love your writing is your complete ability to keep a healthy balance of suspense and hilarity without completely switching gears. *love*


I'd also like to briefly mention this line: When the last owl had found its recipient and flown off, she shrugged and told herself “perhaps tomorrow.” I believe that's as fluffy as Siobhan gets, and it so "Awwwwww!" inducing. It also makes the next moment when she receives the letter so much more endearing. I love it.


Now -- at first, Harry is starting to get on my nerves in this scene. I like him well enough, but his continuous questions and curiosity makes me want to pull my hair. However, I LOVE Siobhan's ways of dealing with this. She's learned so much from Lucius -- she can push Potter out of the way long enough to get where's she going... and at the end, when Harry is simply being such a flobberworm -- she totally beats him flat. XD Oh my lord, I love Siobhan. And I'm beginning to dislike Harry quite a bit. *cough*


When we get to Siobhan and Lucius putting their clothes back on [! btw, we didn't get at least some sort of smutty reward for dealing with Harry's constant interruptions?], they get to the best part of the chapter -- we are shown Lucius' true character, and the suspense of a big argument breaking out is so close to swallowing me that I was dying for something to happen already. Which, it did, since she opened the dainty box [*sniggers*, by the way] to get to the lovely ring. All their banter ceased when she looked on an elegant ring with a sparkling, clear stone setting. There were small engravings, but they were subtle, and the ring was not extravagant at all, but certainly unique. I absolutely LOVE this ring and the moment paired with it. Since the amethyst is my birthstone, and also my favourite semi-precious stone, I have a connection with this ring, and I hope Siobhan keeps it forever and ever. And it's at this moment I realized that Lucius and Siobhan got into their fiesty!banter due to Lucius trying to protect her, and to make sure she'll try and keep herself safe, since he cannot. I love that you put that in, because I've always assumed that a Death Eater, no matter how "close" he/she is to Voldemort, that there is no sure way they can protect anyone close to them. OMG GUH JOYGASM.


And, as Siobhan makes her way to Honeydukes, we find out Harry FOLLOWED her. POTTER, YOU EVIL... GAH. Sorry, getting a little emotional. *cough* Anyways. The fight between them seemed so surreal, like they shouldn't even be fighting. It was phenomenal. "...If you can honestly tell me that it’s your first choice in life to be chased after by a sociopath with a snake fetish —” *DIES* I also liked how Siobhan explained her fate, and the difference between her and Potter [wait, did I just type "Potter"? X.X], although... "...His philosophies are corrupt, and while his arrogance entrances me, it is not something I would love. There is nothing within that man I could ever love.” DAMNIT SIOBHAN, YOU KNOW THAT IS NOT TRUE AND I -- I-- *SOBS*


*cough* Sorry, got emotional again.


This chapter was brilliant! I loved everything about it -- I think that it is one of the few stories I have ever read that made me feel emotional. I'm almost scared of the next chapter -- if it's better than this one -- which, by my theory, it should be -- what the heck is gonna happen next? Lord help us fanboys/girls. X.X