Login
MuggleNet Fan Fiction
Harry Potter stories written by fans!
caren_the_hpfan [Contact]
01/31/05




Hello, you've reached a very long ago abandoned username. I still don't know why I haven't deleted this. Maybe I'm just lazy?

Anyway, I post under the name Aequitas. That's it, really.

If you visited here because you wanted to see A Secret Needed to be Shared or Ad Astra Per Aspera, you're about 3.097 billion years in the past - I deleted them a long time ago. I haven't rewritten them or anything. They died. Haha.


[Report This]


Stories by caren_the_hpfan [0]
Favorite Authors [25]
Favorite Stories [18]
caren_the_hpfan's Favorites [43]
Reviews by caren_the_hpfan


Phases of the Moon by BlackClaude

Rated: 3rd-5th Years •
Summary: In Remus Lupin's fifth year at Hogwarts, his devoted friends finally master the complex Animagus spell, beginning the adventures they will remember for the rest of their lives. But Remus must also face prejudice in the rising war, a test of loyalty versus love, and the danger of his dark secret being revealed.

Pet Peeve Disclaimer: Peter is not worthless, Lily does not have three friends who fall for the Marauders, and no one calls Remus "Remy."
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/16/05 Title: Chapter 4: Lady of Spain

When I first saw the title of this chapter, I was like, "What the...?" Fair ladies of Spain, indeed! I thought that there was some OC from Spain, but not so. Well, she caught Sirius' attention. Doesn't that seem to be the goal of most Marauder-era OCs? And the summary especially made me curious to read, apart from the fact that I wanted to see more of this fic and your writing anyway. :P

Mm, I liked this chapter because it had more of James, and though I do enjoy seeing him, I really like him in character! And he was, and he made me smile. You've kept him from being soppy (ugh) and drooling over Lily (double ugh) and generally out of character. The "Accio Badge!" scene was so well-written. “Wow, if you wanted to tear my robes off, all you had to do was ask,” he said. LOL! I loved that line. It was hilarious to think of Lily roaring too. And then we she wishes she was in Ravenclaw... :D

Oh dear, I'm going out of order here. I love the vivacity of Madam Pomfrey; strict as she is, I can't help smiling as she orders everyone about. LOL at the prank in the Hospital Wing... Compare Dog to Werewolf. Er... (hehe). Sirius' interest in Professor Covas made me raise an eyebrow. Sirius and older woman? I'd never considered that before. I thought he was past girls he really couldn't get at a whim, but I can accept that in your fic. You'll hear me say this over and over again, but: Peter the Marauder! Yes! :D

Oooh, some Lily and Remus. It makes me a bit apprehensive, but it all depends on which direction you take it. Right now they seem like they're going to good friends more than anything. Grrr, I mean later in your fic. Not real life, obviously. :D But the fact they can connect on prejudices is a fair point, though hardly anyone knows Remus is a werewolf. I mean, he can still see the prejudice against others, but it's not quite as real as Lily's prejudice. “So, how are your chimaera wounds healing?” Tehe. Oh, and BTW, Hospital Wing is always capitalized, if you're referring to the one in Hogwarts.

My intrigue in your fic is sparked once again, with another chapter. I didn't comment on any of the characters (except James, of course) because they're all in character so far, even Lily with her gentle moments and flaring temper. LOL. Luckily there's another chapter waiting, so I don't have to write update all over my review. ;)



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 04/09/05 Title: None

Oh dear, every other review is from someone in SPEW and now I have a standard! Well, here it is.

Critique first. "The giggling ensued, followed by a lovely, off – key performance of 'Weasley is Our King.'" --> Why is this in italics? The other conversations are too. Perhaps you forgot to close a tag... "They murmured assent and encouraged her to divulge." --> Instead of "her," try a name... we have no idea who's talking. It may not be important, but "she" is too generalized.

I loved this one-shot and the emotions contained. McKee is a true Slytherin captured at its best - a bit cunning, eager to prove themselves and highly ambitious. An excellent OC, who has a personality. Thank you! :) Too often we see half-baked people with little more than physical descriptions. And Lucius Malfoy's affair made sense. After all, how did he clear his name so easily? Good job, Lex. I'm looking forward to reading more of your writing.

Author's Response: Thank you for reviewing (I'll pretend like I didn't know you would..hee hee)! I'll take a look at the items you've mentioned. I like to vary the use of pronouns and nouns, so that is probably my reasoning behind using 'she' in that sentence. Besides, as the fiction is in her head, the reader can figure out what is going on anyhow. I'll take a look at Weasley is our King to see if it's awkward in any way. I'm glad you enjoyed my snotty little McKee. I appreciate it!

Author's Response: Have located the song! It is in italics- along with the rest of the sentence- because it happens in the past. You see her reaction to the juvenile song in the next paragraph. Again, thank you.



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 03/11/05 Title: None

This story is so interesting! After reading a lot of James/Lily fics told from their point of view, it's nice to read a Marauder told from Remus' point of view. You force your readers to visualize the situation in a good way, but I think you can show a little more, not tell. It's better to say, "Her pretty features lit up her face," instead of "She was pretty." You did well the first couple of times, but some parts got a little dull. You're a good writer with fine grammar but could use a little help with your spelling, I think. The situation between Michelle and Sirius is going to be fun to watch/read! And Lily and James are very in character. No one is OOC - not yet! :) Overall, the story merits a well-deserved ten.

Author's Response: Thank you so much, i love the constructice criticsm. It's exactly what i need! I hope i get the next chapter in soon enough! Thank you.



Year Seven: Harry Potter & The Blood Debt by GringottsVault711

Rated: 1st-2nd Years •
Summary: Harry, heavy with the summer's grief and his future's burden, begins his final year at Hogwarts. He will hide something from his two best friends, but he isn't the only one keeping secrets; there's a mysterious organization on the rise, and Hogwarts is under fire from the public. The truth about the past will be revealed, while secrets of the present are hidden, and Harry must struggle to find his own sense of morality, all while knowing that his destiny is to kill. SEQUEL to Harry's Sixth Year. This story is PRE-HBP
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 07/01/05 Title: Chapter 18: Chapter 18: Snape's Duty

I suppose I should bless you with a "Caren review," but I'm too tired, and thought it's almost 2 here, my body says around 4. *shrug* Hey, I'm bored. Anyway, I can't help but love the clever ending you wrote in, with Harry's Legilemency and all. I never read your Year Six, as you well know, but I can't help but wonder how the process of breaking into someone's mind is. Going out on a limb here... *glances nervously at ground*... wouldn't there be more of a struggle? Sure, Snape's defences were low, but I can't help but wonder if that was all in Snape's mind. It couldn't have been the only thing. There must have been more flashbacks. Perhaps Harry had to struggle with clearing them away before "experiencing" that memory. Just my thoughts. Don't stop updating - okay, as if you'd stop - but here's another demand for another chapter. I know it's written, hurry up and post it! :D -- Your fangirl. ;)



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 03/24/05 Title: None

It's your lovely beta speaking! I loved it - and loved the subtle changes too! I always have to laugh at Erica's label, The Strangest Yet. It was very good! If you reread it and make sure to break paragraphs apart, then it would look wonderful. Great job. I only helped you edit it, remember that. I'm not taking any credit for your story.

Author's Response: Oh, i know, but im very very happy you did help me with it it looks loads better now thankeee!!!!!



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 03/22/05 Title: None

This is going to be a long and boring review going in chronological order in response to your nice review! So here it is... "Her plump figure sat at the table while she was sipping a cup of hot, steamy Espresso. As Harry took some of the massive pile of eggs and bacon, Mrs. Weasley looked over and exclaimed, "Why Harry, There is plenty of food, you don't need to go and starve yourself to death. You always know that you are welcome to take as much as you need."" Using precise aim. Add a comma after it too. But it's so funny - Draco throwing darts at pictures? :D But how did Mrs. Weasley's dress knock a glass of water over? Maybe her elbow did it. And I'm not too sure Ginny would bark. Snap, maybe. Also, throughout the chapter you have verb tense problems. If they did something, they're not going to be doing something with an "-ing" ending in the same sentence. I just took your entire chapter apart, and I'm sorry for sounding cynical. I just wanted to critique yours a bit more as a favor for reviewing mine. I think it's a good story overall, it's got both H/G and R/Hr elements. Those are pretty general but not OOC at all. Good job!

Author's Response: Thanks so much for all of your help. I will try and add a little more detail in as you requested and about the tense thing. I think part of the problem may be that I first wrote it in present tense, and later switched to past. Maybe this will clear it up. Again, thank you so much for the review!



Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 03/22/05 Title: None

Er, somehow a lot of my review vanished. Not quite sure how, but about the first quote: Try using contractions more often. It allows for more natural dialogue and creates more realistic characters. Also, why is Molly sipping espresso? Does she need the caffeine boost?

Author's Response: Ok thanks for the tip. Umm, wouldn't it be tiring to be looking after those kids for quite some time... There may also be another reason that I can't tell you.



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/20/05 Title: None

Well, Vader, thought I'd stop being selfish and sticking to my favorites list, and branch out. Nice title - it drew me in. And, of course, the very first thought connecting "wrongfully accused" to Azkaban is Sirius Black, but you included that it was an OC in your summary. I read too fast. LOL.

I've always tried to imagine Azkaban, and totally failed. (I don't own the British versions, BTW.) Now I have a much clearer picture - the earthy floor, puddle of mud, cold stone walls and rusted iron bars of the window. Great imagery. Shouldn't that be what GI stands for? ;) And especially the description of his nightmares. It does deserve that PG-13 rating, though. A bit graphic. And I liked how you clued us in about him: I can hear wicked and cruel laughter; laughter that is not my own. No one believes me.

The Priori Incantato made me think a bit. Maybe I'm being too obvious (better to be thought a fool, I suppose), but the only thing I an derive is that someone took his wand. Forcefully? There's no mention of a struggle between him and the offending person. Wouldn't there be? Wouldn't that be the person he has nightmares about? We only hear about some laughter. Male or female? I think you're trying to keep us in the dark. Just some inquisitive questions from a reader. :P

How is this... man... able to survive against the dementors? I'm guessing he's been there three years, since I'm assuming Lucius & DE's escape in Harry's sixth year. He really is innocent (I'm pretty sure he's not mad, hehe), so why don't you dwell on that more? Azkaban is a lot more psychological than normal, Muggle prisons. It's not only the walls and claustrophia, lack of freedom and little hope, but the dementors suck out the soul... life. Sirius Black is a very strong-willed person, and even if he was in there much longer, he had to resist them somehow. I'm curious as to why this man doesn't seem affected at all.

Azkaban the prison. What are the doors like? You mentioned they were of steel. Also, there must be some small opening at the bottom to allow the food. And how did that dementor get in so easily? Did it open the door? As far as I know, they can't glide through walls. And is there a small window through which he can look? He has to observe Lucius, Bellatrix and the others somehow. He just gazes out of his door. Clarification?

Your writing is excellent - clean and yet descriptive. Everything seems well-thought over except for (maybe) my really nitpicky comments. The plot is fascinating, and has no holes so far; perfectly sound. Why wouldn't an unknown be imprisoned by Cornelius Fudge for crimes he didn't commit, and escape with the Death Eaters? Why wouldn't Lucius escape with the help of Bellatrix and the Dementors? (Well, not exactly help, but certainly not hindrance.) Well done, and I really should read more of your writing.



A Match Made by Law by LariLee

Rated: Professors •
Summary: A slightly twisted, but highly realistic, possibly humorous, and very late, look at the Marriage Law Challenge. Mentions character deaths (but not HG or SS) and has some possible squickiness in passing that results in an "R" Rating. No house-elves were harmed in the writing of this ficlet, who I cannot say the same of Cornelius Fudge, Minister of Magic.
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/13/05 Title: Chapter 1: A Match Made by Law

Jenna recommended this fic for me (which is not surprising by the review she left below.... or above), and wow, how I laughed. The first couple paragraphs, I wondered where the humor was, and realized it was staring me in the face! You've combined a serious tone and an uproarious plot to create this excellent one-shot! Those are always the funniest!

LOL at everyone's fates! Harry with the cognitive skills of a piece of celery and as the Boy-Whose-Luck-Ran-Out, Ron choking on the Snitch... oh wow. That was so hilarious. And also when you started listing prices... *wipes away tears of laughter* OMG when Amadia Fudge testified....! The idea of an old grandmother desperately wanting to shag men in Azkaban was pure genius. And I hope the house-elves are still feeding the poor Muggle milkman - after all he's been through!

Crabbe and Goyle! "Hey, thanks Snape!” Crabbe said, taking the vial. That casual attitude made me laugh my head off, and especially when they fought over Fudge. (!) And um, can I just copy and paste all the paragraphs about Amadia's chaos? I can't? Aww. I'd love to! That dear old lady is precious! Escape attempts by wizards incarcerated there went up by 1002% in the first month. LOL!

The entire thing is just precious; I'm sticking this on my faves and probably never taking it off. This look at the MLC just cracked me up. Tell your poor plot bunny that his idea was great, okay? I'll never look at Cornelius Fudge with the same eyes ever, ever again.

Author's Response: Thank you so much, caren_the_hpfan! I was finally able to login and let you know how much your review means to me! I am just so happy you enjoyed it. Thank you! And the bunny thinks you too!
~Lisa



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/12/05 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 2: Separate Paths

MJ, this story is getting even better! Your imagery (however graphic, lol) is wonderful and drew me into the story numerous times. I also loved the intertwining stories - I'm not confused yet! All the dates make sense so far - though I had to think for a moment to make sure I was keeping events in the right order. ;) Silly old me.

I think Neville's occupation as a Healer is very fitting - even if he has to work with Potions. But the only obstacle was Professor Snape after all, so now I'm not surprised he excels in it. The moonstone amulet and spoken password are very creative and quite clever, because they're believable too. But I'm wondering what the tablet is made of. My first impression was stone, but they wouldn't be that medieval, would they? It said in OotP that Healers made notes on clipboards. The parchment could be enchanted. But that's my take - this is your fic.

Ooh, Jenna did a good job, apparently; both Hermione and Ron were very much in character! “You can read? Really?” came Hermione’s retort, dripping with sarcasm. “And here I thought I was the one who did all your reading for you…” Hehe. Yup, that was Hermione right there. It might me sigh to think of Ron catching a hold of before she left. They're so perfect together! *almost squeals* :D

Ah, the scene between Ginny and Neville. You described her state with so much imagery I really was afraid she was never going to come back, but I sort of decided that you needed her for your plot. ;) I'm not much of a Neville/Ginny shipper, but that scene was so sweet and touching.“He isn’t coming back, is he?” she whispered. “Voldemort?” asked Neville, bravely. Mmm. Pure genius.

Next part was written nicely too, from Molly's point of view. A glimpse of the family was needed at that point, as they were completely shut out (and will be). And that makes me sad to know that Molly doesn't realise that Ron and Hermione have been sleeping together. She truly is in the dark. And Harry! Amelia Bones as Minister, not surprising at all. Harry running to Amelia: interesting. Well, I can he would just because she's part of the Order (I would think) and she has connections. Is that about right?

The wedding night was well-written as far as the naive part of me says. I loved how gentle Neville was to Ginny, though. And how he never, ever put himself first, but put her as first priority. That was love right there. “You may not be ready to believe this,” he whispered in a rough voice, “but I’ll just keep telling you until you do. I love you.” Oh, Neville. That was wonderful, MJ. I can't imagine how Ginny and Neville will have to explain to their families and friends - so hurry up and post the next chapter, darn it! I can't wait!

Here's some more nitpicking (because I know you love it, lol): The young woman lay perfectly still, her deathly pale face framed by her long red hair and her body was shrouded in white sheets. I would take out the "was" after body, seeing as there is no verb after "pale face." "OWL" and "NEWT" are initials, therefore they look like "O.W.L." and "N.E.W.T." I think you might have forgotten a few commas too --> “No,” affirmed Neville feeling ashamed. Between Neville and feeling. "Why Neville?" [Ginny] and “You’re beautiful Ginny,” he began softly. After "why" and "beautiful." I also want to see more of Rhea. She seems levelheaded, but as far as being a "Muggle" goes, wouldn't she be shocked? At all?

Grr, I just realized there isn't another chapter I can read! You. Need. To. Update. Put the chats through hellfire, I don't care. ;) Just... update! Haha. I won't recap everything and make you wonder if the review is ever going to end, just tell you I love it so far. Mmm.

Author's Response: Wow! I think this review might almost be as long as the chapter... :) Thank-you for the wonderful reviews! I was rather surprised to see you ventured over to this fic, but I'm so glad you did! I hope you continue to enjoy it!



Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/12/05 Title: Chapter 1: Prologue: A Peaceful Life

Hey MJ, I was checking to see if ASL had been updated, then decided I should see if you wrote anything else. :P So here I am! Needless to say, your summary totally drew me in. (Not the R-rated part, of course!) But I'm really interested on seeing Harry 15 years after his wizarding life and with no magic, too.

The first part was wonderful. I totally got lost in the beautiful descriptions, and seeing as I'm staring at a computer screen, that's not very easy to do! At the first mention of the car (subtle: yes) I perked up even more, eager to see the life devoid of magic. And also the fact that her daughter was eleven. We all know that's quite a magical number. :D

Hmm. So Rhea can talk to snakes? Or at least, they can talk to her? Interesting! And the sports, of course, make sense. She is Harry's daughter after all. I like how you gave us glimpses of their life - first from Sara, then Rhea, then Harry. And I was in shock for two seconds when I realized the chapter was over - you drew me in so deeply I didn't notice how short it was! I just sort of stared at the page.

Your imagery was simply amazing from beginning to end, and your tone was definitely a lot different than your other fic, but I rather like it. It gives the story more of an air of mystery. Looking forward to everyone's lives now - Sara's, Rhea's, Harry's, even Morgan's. I also want to see what happened to everyone else! On to the next chapter!



Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/12/05 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 1: The End of an Age

Um, am I supposed to say something. Er... wow. Amazing. This chapter was written beautifully, all parts, even though my younger self sort of shies away from the rape scene. I was warned, though, so what can I say? Other than it was just beautiful. Now I'm getting repetitive.

Here's some nitpicking for you: the "number" in "number 12, Grimmauld Place" should be capitalized, spells are always italicized ("Crucio!") and "sweat slick" has a hyphen --> "sweat-slick." In "Cruciatus curse," all of it should be capitalized. Also, "entranceway" (towards the end) sounds a bit awkward - try substituting "entryway."

I found it odd that Rhea wasn't shocked by the fact owls flew up to her - that they carried letters! I'm assuming she hasn't been familiar with owls, since Harry (apparently) hasn't seen Hedwig in years. How often does one see an owl, much less one that will come near, and even carry a letter? If I were Rhea, I'd be in shock. After all, in the Sorceror's Stone, seeing owls by daytime was astonishing enough. The only thing that seemed to make her gasp was that her name was on the letters.

Now I sound harsh, but not at all. The rape scene was actually written well enough to keep me interested in your writing. It wasn't too graphic, but it's the mind of the reader that determines that, I suppose. The part with him torturing Bellatrix was understandable by all means. Loving this so far, and moving on to the next chapter!



I Have Seen Them Change by x2pttrclue32

Rated: 1st-2nd Years •
Summary: I have seen them grow, change, and bond from a distance. They have never ceased to amaze me. What they have accomplished throughout the years is incredible, and I envy them. But with accomplishment also comes pain. How do they live when pain is preying on them? How do they go on when death is calling their names? They have suffered greatly, and that I do not envy…
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 05/21/05 Title: Chapter 1: One-Shot

I'm finally going to review you! One of these days, I'm going to review everyone from SPEW, but that day is long in coming, I think. I always like reviewing one-shots, just because I don't have to read previous chapters. Okay, I'll review...

First, I think spelling Gryffindor correctly would help. You managed to spell incorrectly it two different ways. ;) As we left the castle, he looked saddened, as if some great treasure had been snatched from him. That's an excellent observation on Susan's part. Her noticing Harry lamenting Sirius' need to hide is very believable.

I liked the description of the third task. As short as it is, I can imagine the way it sounded when Fleur screamed and everyone suddenly became quiet, and the way it sounded when Cedric screamed. I think you could have mentioned the red sparks and the worry they brought to the crowd. And I think that "anticipation turned into horror."

The way that Susan described Hermione had a hint of animosity in it, that she wasn't too fond of her. It seemed that Susan thinks she is better than Hermione for some reason, be it that she's not bossy or a know-it-all. Also, it seemed to dwell on what Hermione has done. Describe Hermione for a bit - the personality that you can't see on the outside. Susan, from the way she's described Harry, has a lot of insight on other people. Maybe it's just Harry, but a little more will suffice.

Ron was my favorite, hands down. Mentioning the shadow of his brothers is essential to understanding Ron at all, because it was, at first, who he was. A shadow of the older Weasleys. Including the first train ride to Hogwarts was clever too. That's when he started to really change.

I thought this was good overall. These are only suggestions, and if you'd like to, leave your fic alone - it's fine enough. This is the first I've read of your work, and it's very encouraging!

Author's Response: *headdesl* I spelled Gryffindor wrong. Gah. Thanks for the review!

Author's Response: *headdesk* *headesk Death to moochie.



When Saints Die, The World Stops Spinning by forsakenphoenix

Rated: 1st-2nd Years • Past Featured Story
Summary: Hope, loyalty, love, despair, and tragedy. Through it all, Lily discovers the truth about the Marauders, the affable troublemakers who hide behind smokescreens but still glitter in shattered light. They aren't the glorious, graceful men they are often perceived as, but stumbling, awkward boys who are still trying to find their way out of darkness.
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/07/05 Title: Chapter 1: When Saints Die, The World Stops Spinning

This story was recommended to me by a friend, and I'm impressed with her choice. I love Marauder fics, but this one-shot is one of the best I've seen so far. And I wouldn't take that so lightly. I think I'll have to read Unveiled Secrets now, to see more of your writing. ;)

The very first thing that drew me in was the tense. I read and reread the first sentence, trying to see if I had missed anything. Surely it's not in present tense, I told myself. But it was! And you managed to keep it perfected for the rest of the one-shot. Since reading that, I suppose a little light went off and I was on the lookout for any slips. But I couldn't find any; good job at that.

Peter... It's when I read fics like yours that my hatred for him grows a bit softer. You portrayed him as human. That's some hard work. And you showed us his weakness without overdoing it too, and not making him too pathetic. He wasn't OOC at all. And I thought it interesting how you described Sirius as a King (for emphasis). He certainly was a "constellation of frustration." I smiled as I read that, because I knew exactly who was next. Sirius, the golden boy, now crowned king. Lily as his "mother" is very fitting; in fact, that is her "position" in one of my fics. I really think that that was part of her friendship with Sirius.

Ah, Remus. That part was my favorite. 'Tis beautiful in all senses. Your language was careful to evoke the right emotions - at least, it worked on me. Remus has always meant comfort to me too. I'll leave it at that. Suffice it to say that your writing reflected my feelings.

I thought it odd how you never mentioned Sirius at the wedding, though I know that that part was Remus' part of the story. He was best man, after all. Shouldn't he at least been described? The youthfulness in his face that we know about? And the rest of the fic was amazing. None of the glimpses in the married life were too short nor too long, just enough for us. Your scene with the Secret-Keeper (BTW, remember to include a dash) was well-explained too. I thought it interesting that it was James who opposed to it, not Lily. And my favorite line -->And she waits beside his cradle, waits for the world to stop spinning. *sigh* I loved your fic. Thanks for contributing to fan fic, and I hope you continue writing.



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 04/28/05 Title: None

*sigh* Yes, it's up! Though I was disappointed when I saw the title... :P What about, "As the Toilet Flushed?" Or all those other "great" ones? Just kidding... Anyway, you did get this one-shot posted really fast, and I applaud you. An impatient person like me who likes your writing can't stand waiting.

Haha...critique! (My favorite part!) I had to reread to be able to give you a constructive criticism - which is good! No glaringly obvious technical errors. Each time, Remus would shake his head, thinking, Why didn’t you come up with a better excuse for missing days each month? Surely you didn’t think they would accept the excuse of illness, did you? It sounds here as if he's trying to challenge "normal" people to bear his burden. In that case, he would say, "Why don't you..." and "Surely you don't think..." My friends, my classmates, the Order, the fear, the running, it’s all over. Here he's taking the information very slowly (or so it seems). He would have to come to the conclusion after a pause. Perhaps an ellipsis (...) after "running" would be better? The realisation never quite hit him forcefully. He said nothing, his hands gripping the chair in front of him, not wanting to accept what he had just learned. "He said nothing as his hands gripped the chair..." The comma sounds a bit awkward, though the original tense of "grip" is fine. About the moon charm... could you elaborate a bit more on that? That was the incriminating evidence for him being Voldemort's little helper, so it would have more importance. Where/when did he lose it? Does he have a suspicion Wormtail has it? It can’t be! he thought. make sure you italicise the "It can't be!" part of it. It can’t be! he thought again. He yells after this thought. It could be screamed in his head or the like. It would help with building up to his "NO!" I've heard you discuss this, but I don't think Mrs. Peabody would know Sirius was the Secret-Keeper - not so soon, I mean. She has her sources, but wouldn't Remus ask how she knew?

Also, could you add a little bit more to Mrs. Peabody's character? She hovers between matronly and friendly at times, and even though she is an OC with no great significance (at least I think so), you could place her in one category. She seems more motherly than a close friend, so don't hesitate to add more! I loved when she asked him to call her Marie - it developed her character nicely. Remus' emotions are very well understood, and the part about writing to Mr. Caruthers was funny. This is so long - I apologise if I went too far. ;) Remus' PoV of the Gift of Love storyline was very refreshing, though full of angst. You did an excellent job! As always, I look forward to seeing more of your writing, namely companion fics. Keep on going, Em! Love it!



Author's Response: Aw... You don't think Gone fits? ;) Don't worry, I'm sure you'll have fun helping me find a title to my Sirius One-Shot. It's going to be a while before my next One-Shot is posted. I can't decide whether I want to turn in my Peter or Sirius fic in next. They're out of chronologically anyway. *shrugs* I'll figure it out eventually, I suppose.

Thanks for the con crit. I'll change it around so that it's more clear that Remus is thinking to himself and not others. And as for the hands gripping the chair... My betas said gripped, so I'll go by what they say, lol. Remus has long learned that Mrs Peabody has her ways of knowing things. He marvels at the scope of information she possesses. (I myself am amazed at what she knows...) And stay tuned my dear Caren. Mrs Peabody will explored in a one shot about how she and Remus meet. (It's kind of sad, though.)



A Grandmother's Tale by Magical Maeve

Rated: 1st-2nd Years • Past Featured Story
Summary: A little character exploration. How did Neville's Gran take the news of her son's torture and what does she really think of her grandson?
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 05/22/05 Title: Chapter 1: A Grandmother's Tale

This is the first I've read of a point of view from Neville's grandmother, and I must say, I liked it. From what we have from Neville, she is portrayed as a strict, uncaring sort of person, blunt and not sensitive. Your portrayal, however, makes her much more real. I wouldn't be surprised if JKR described Mrs Longbottom like that.

My first comment is on the vocabulary. Since I follow HPDL, I'm more familiar with your writing style, but I was pleased with the more old-fashioned style you wrote. From the first paragraph on, I could hear an old lady really talking to me. And the way she gets off of the topic is so typical of elderly woman! The way she says she has to "disgress" reminds me of someone elderly I know. Nice job.

Mentioning her family's loss of former fortune was nicely done, too. She always seemed to carry that hint of old money long gone - and struggling to overcome the fact that she is much poorer. And I love the fact that Neville practically inherited his fondness of plants, because his great-great-grandfather owned herb farms.

And oh, I could see Alice and Frank. Alice "once lovely" and looking only asleep on her hospital bed, Frank "turned into [my] little boy again." And Mrs Longbottom pulling out a clean handkerchief to obsessively wipe his drool away...! Once again, typical elderly woman.

In the very last part of your one-shot, you could have explored what Neville's life was going to be like now that his parents are unable to raise him. This boy's life has changed, radically. In essence, he is an orphan, being left to be raised by relatives. Also, she doesn't seem to care about him much. Was that intentional? It's evident in OotP that she isn't too affectionate, but she could at least care more about his current state.

I liked it! I'm so used to anticipating the next chapter with Harry Potter and the Daughter of Light. For such a good writer at long-term fics, you're great on short-terms fics too. Excellent job! I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.

Author's Response: Thanks for the review, Caren! Having spent a lot of my childhood in Lancashire it wasn't too hard for me to find material for Gran Longbottom. She's a trypical Lancastrian matriarch with a fded past, clinging to her genteel life. What she hadn't expected was to have to take care of her young grandson and I plan on coming back to explore her years with Neville. I'm pleased that you thought I had captured her voice well. As a young child I was often forced to sit and listen to aging female relatives and Gran became an amalgamation of them all.



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 05/20/05 Title: None

I feel stupid now... when you said your one-shot had only three reviews, I thought you meant Gone. How wrong I am...! So I'm reviewing for you!

Wow. The first part was hilarious. I didn't even know who was talking, so I just kind of sat there reading it, and wondering how you wrote so mushily. And I almost fell out of my chair when I saw it was Sirius talking to his motorbike. LOL. And his trying to amuse Peter was so characteristic of him.

Sirius noted the Daily Prophets perfectly aligned on the coffee table, not an inch out of place. :: pernickety mode :: Did you mean more than one edition of the Daily Prophet? You could clarify that by saying they were "all perfectly aligned..." And that was just funny! I can imagine Peter's home in my mind clearly... rooms with no decoration, everything exactly in place, always silent.

And here the drama begins. I think that the dialogue between Sirius and Peter at the first mentioned demolished house ('cause there's two, obviously) was very IC - Peter stuttered and was petrified of saying anything and Sirius insulted Voldemort offhandedly. And the way Peter introduced the moon charm was a pure act of cowardice. Grrr... It makes me angry to think of filthy, rotten betrayers. But moving on... Again the air pressed against his face, but now, to Sirius, it felt like an oppressive force him, trying to keep him from his destination. Oo, I like it. Really. Everything always works against someone with another to save. And the way you interjected Sirius' thoughts with the action, or the other way around was fitting. And how you incorporated the dialogue that JKR has given us was well done. Looking at your fic from outsider's eyes (say, Hagrid) Sirius does look like the betrayer. No wonder everyone thought it was he, not Peter.

Yet another great companion fic! Nice work, and I hope you get more reviews. Don't convince yourself that it's not good due to the reviews. Sometimes people read and don't have time to review.

Author's Response: Thank you Caren for your review. I've come to look forward to what you have to say, since you put so much great detail into your reviews and I really feel like you've gotten the sense of what the story is about. I'm glad to see that you like how I've written young Sirius and that you liked the contrast in how he felt about his bike at the beginning of the chapter and the end. I hope you'll continue to review for me and come back when I've submitted Power, about Peter. :)



by

Rated:
Summary:
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/02/05 Title: None

Mmhmm. I'm reviewing another one-shot of yours! I think I read it with a more prejudiced mind than usual -- I don't like Peter Pettigrew, and I don't think I ever will. *sigh* But you brought to him to life without any sort of judgment -- that is, we couldn't tell if you hated/loved him. (Though I can imagine...) It was clean, devoid of the usual urge to turn him into a monster. I rather appreciated that. It was interesting to see the real Peter for once.

The scene with Remus and Peter was a bit confusing. I understood that Remus needed to go to Egypt, but where were they in the first place? Were they not in London? It would help to organize the events more, I think. But I liked the reason why Peter ended up taking it -- that he might use it to his own advantage. So much like the cowardly Peter we've been introduced to.

I forgot what "SI" meant (the trigger warning) until I read the last part. That Peter was strong enough to even contemplate suicide was very intriguing. And I laughed when he put the knife back because it was too dirty. The irony! In his almost last moments, all Peter thinks about is how immaculate something is. *snort* It's sort of like the irony that they sterilize needles that are used for lethal injections. And it's so fitting that right before he was to cut himself, the Dark Lord stopped him by calling him. It's only the "Darkest One" that'll ever stop him, not his morals or sense of well-being. I also liked the fact that Peter called Voldemort the "Darkest One." Coward... *grr*

To bring it all together, I rather liked it. Fanfic continually opens my mind to see inside of people I normally block off as people I simply don't like. Thank you for the nice insight into Peter. I also liked your title -- "Power" -- for it spoke volumes. Less is more, eh? Very nice! I notice that you have each of the Marauders now, and I hope your continue writing, even if it's not a companion fic to Gift of Love. :D

Author's Response: Thank you so much for your sweet review! I always like hearing from you. Or rather, reading from you... *frowns* Does that make any sense? Anyway, thanks for pointing out your confusion about where Remus and Peter were. I hadn't thought it was terribly important so I didn't think much of it. I'll be keeping that in mind though in future One shots. Hopefully you'll come and read? Yeah? I'm glad you liked this and that you thought I portrayed him in a way that you were able to see him in spite of your bias. And really, we're all biased, aren't we?



Sins of the Father by TheVault

Rated: Professors •
Summary: There was something about him that made him irresistible to her. Siobhan Murphy will go to any lengths to ascertain her deepest desires - but when the object of those desires is a married man twice her age with secrets darker than she can imagine, she will find herself caught in a scandalous liaison that she can't walk away from. Not Canon-Compliant.
Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 06/07/05 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1: Dangerous Attraction

Jenna, I was starting to wonder if your story would ever appear - after seeing your cool banner over and over. And here it is! Yes! I've heard too much about it, so I figured it must be better than great from MJ and Em. And guess what? It is! I haven't read much of your writing except R/Hr one-shots, which obviously wasn't enough. I have a feeling that Harry Potter and the Blood Debt might become a must-read. Okay... review. And that means concrit. :)

First for a few grammar mistakes I caught... I know you have to describe original characters a lot more than a usual writer, because Siobhan doesn't know their names. So, when using terms like "brown haired," I would suggest changing them to "brown-haired." There are a few other instances, such as "bushy haired," "dirty blonde" and "round faced." This would also apply to "green laced" and "thestral drawn." Also, on the subject of Luna's hair - there shouldn't be a comma after "blonde."

On Ginny's outburst, I'm questioning her sudden inability to speak with proper grammar. I don’ want to discuss what colors the walls are! Does she really mean "don'?" Why does nobody want to talk about it? And why wouldn't she say, "Why doesn't anybody want to talk about it?" She may be emotionally distraught, but it's not my first instinct to speak in her manner. And on "Well, Miss. Murphy - each of us..." Should there be a period after "miss?"

Oh, and by the way - I love Siobhan. (I love her name too - 'tis awesome. And beautiful.) Her personality is addictive, and to get inside her head is more bait than I can handle. ;) She fascinates me, especially the way she views others. I can tell that her vocabulary has been well-chosen - not one of a total intellectual, but one truly unique to her character. I almost smiled when she thought of Harry Potter as only a "boy." There's nothing else I can say about her. You've done a wonderful job of carefully constructing your OC.

And Draco is very much in character; you caught his swagger, scowl and drawl just right. I could see him leaning into her compartment and smiling as he left. Great imagery and nice characterization. And, of course, Lucius. I liked the clever way you introduced his wife - "The woman, with a gold band around her ring finger..." - and, unfortunately, the way he sent her off. Power is so intoxicating. ;) And a wow at how many times you mentioned a reference to cold in the very first paragraph without being repetitive. It certainly describes Lucius!

I thought it odd that she had a cat with her. She seemed too distant on the outside to show that kind of affection - but then, this is the first chapter. Hopefully that cat won't be so much of hanger-on than usual. :D And the part when the yellow walls of the compartment were mentioned, I nearly laughed, then remembered what I was reading. LOL. The bond between the six in the carriage, excluding Siobhan of course, seems a lot stronger, and communicated with what I like to call an economy of language - not too verbose but giving us exactly what we need.

*blink* Have I given you too much concrit? I just thought I'd mention anything that came to mind as I read. Anyway, it's great that this is the first chapter. This story has enormous potential, and I think you are quite up to the challenge. An excellent read that will stay on my favorites for a very, very long time! Awesome to see it (finally) and even better to read it! Here's the usual from me: please update (!), because I'm an annoyingly impatient person, and I need more of Siobhan and the story. Looking forward to chapter two!



Author's Response: Thank you so much! Favorite review of all time, I swear!

I went ahead and fixed the errors you pointed out, thank you very much. I'm so glad you like Siobhan's character - that's one of the best compliments a writer can receive. About Mian - Siobhan may *seem* distant, but no matter what way you look at it, she needs a companion, no? Cats are pretty independent, anyway. Besides, Siobhan isn't what she seems.

I'm trying to reach my potential with this story, and with all of my more recent works - so my R/Hr one-shots and Harry's Sixth Year will seem very different in style and quality, to say the least.

Thanks so much, dearest! This has made my day! A lovely early birthday gift, indeed.



Reviewer: caren_the_hpfan Signed
Date: 09/12/05 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2: Something of Interest

Jenna! I can't believe it's taken this long for me to review. You know I love Soft (and Siobhan) to no end. It's just that my thoughts wouldn't formulate themselves into reviews... argh, stupid little things.

Yes, anyway. Your review! Warning: I actually printed out your chapter, so I'm going to be extra nitpicky. (Fun fun!) There were two paragraphs that needed formatting: the ones starting with "Sorry," Siobhan shrugged uncaringly before sitting down. and "What are you all chatting about?" bared McGonagall, who had clearly lost her patience with the class. (For some reason, formatting and McGonagall goes together; don't ask me why. ;)) Just an enter is needed.

Two more nitpicky things before I launch into my SPEWing mode: replace "to" with "at" in: Why the bloody hell is he passing me a note? Siobhan thought to herself, eyeing the parchment with disgust and raising a condescending brow to Goyle. Nearly sounds as if her brow is moving toward him. :P Also: "I take it you're Miss Murphy?" [Harry] asked, a slight amused grin tugging at his lips. Add an "ly" to the end of "slight."

In the Transfiguration class, did Mr Thomas, Miss Brown and Miss Patil all make NEWT level? I need to check HBP, but it just struck me as odd that they all excel in Transfiguration. I notice Seamus Finnigan isn't there, but is that it? I thought that either Lavender or Parvati wouldn't make it. Isn't it kind of funny that nearly all the Gryffindors made it that far?

Potter looked at her as though she might be touched in the head, but then nodded in agreement. "Alright then...", and he snapped one of the toes from his frog and put it in front of one of the mice, who sniffed it cautiously.

I would suggest taking off the comma on the underlined part, or even better, reforming the sentence into something like, "With an 'Alright then,' he snapped one of the toes from his frog. . . ." (Etc.)

On the paragraph starting with Not bothering to be careful or quiet... remove one set of dashes. It's too repetitive and stands out to the reader. I would suggest substituting commas for the first instance, and including a "which" and commas on the second one. And on Perhaps, Draco, you would like to inform me why you have lured me here tonight... - take out the ellipsis and put in a period or a question mark. It is a question, after all. One more: He moved closr to her, wearing a much mistake look of satisfaction at his skills of seduction Period at the end, m'dear.

Siobhan turned to see that the Draco's goblet of poison had been knocked all over Hermione Granger, whose robes were sizzling dangerously. Two things: take out the "the" in front of Draco, and describe Hermione's face. Is she that shocked to simply stand there? Wouldn't she be fuming, snarling, or at least glaring at Draco ferociously? (Hehe.) Hermione usually has a quick reaction, and show it.

Long as this may be, don't be in doubt that I loved it! Omgoodness, how I love the Slytherin in Siobhan, like Siobhan wasn't sure how to respond, so she didn't. Unless Professor McGonagall wanted her to go back in time in order to attain punctuality, there wasn't much that could be done. LOL! *laughs her head off* And Draco as her "pale-faced object of her enmity." Oh my crazy, how hilarious. Oh yes... Then, apparently choosing to use an entire different method, his lips raced towards hers with alarming velocity, and she felt his already open mouth collide with the bottom half of her face. I can picture that perfectly! Hahaha...

I thought this was just priceless. You are Siobhan, inside and out. ;) The dialogue was excellent, well done, and so was the interaction. I can't wait for the next chapter! Draco had better cooperate with Siobhan this time, or I might have to come after him. *glares* Ahh! I'm sitting impatiently for the rest, hurry up and post! (Even if I have to go and bother whoever's betaing for you.) :D (Oh, and wow... I put so many tags into this review, I think I might have forgotten to close one. I'm looking it over, but my bad if something goes wrong.)



Author's Response: Thanks for the nitpicks. I'm sure I'll get around to fixing them... eventually. *cough*

Anyway, hehe, thanks for the review, I'm glad you're enjoying it, and I love that you put so much effort on the feedback :)