Oh and I forgot to mention that, as usual, your humor is great. I loved Charlie's line " Hey, Ginny, are you going to introduce your boyfriend to your brothers - Barry isn't it?"
In this way you've really captured both Rowling's world and the Weasley family specifically.
Author's Response: There's lot's of humour in Harry Potter and I like to put it in my wok too. Thanks for the review
I like this =)
This is well thought out.
I like that your story is about James. That makes it unique since most of the next gen stuff is about Albus or Lily, with James as a side character.
Oh and one question: who currently has the Marauder's Map?
Author's Response: I'm so glad you like it! I think James is a unique personality that is too often glossed over as well.
At this time in the story, Harry still has the Marauder's Map. I like the idea that James, just like Harry, had to learn the secrets of the castle in stages - a little without the Map, and then some with the Map. I didn't want James to be given all the tools right off the bat. But I think he'll be receiving it soon!
Thank you so much for reading and reviewing!
-Ethan
This chapter just made me smile a lot =)
Good characterization and a good way to introduce the idea that Harry will be proposing to Ginny without too much fluff. Keep this up =)
Ahhhh! Cliffhanger! =)
Yet again, well written and enjoyable to read.
This whole story was just great! It really made me smile.
Author's Response: Thank you very much. I enjoyed writing it. ~Carole~
I really like your characters. You have done a good job making them interesting and likeable. I would like to see more stories about them in the future.
Author's Response: Hi again, Sydney. I'm glad you read this story too. There's always a risk in writing Original Characters because some readers only want to read about the major characters in the books. But that can eventually get boring. I wanted to branch out into someone a little different, so I wrote about the transfer students who were mentioned in Chapter 11 of Deathly Hallows, where Remus reads about them in the newspaper.
I have also always wondered about wizarding agriculture; where do they get their groceries? It's true that kids who grow up on farms are different from kids who don't grow up on farms; they are generally more pragmatic, more competent, more creative, and they are used to taking adult responsibilities from an early age. Compare this to Draco, who was so eager to become a Death Eater so that he could feel like an adult; Howard has considered himself to be an adult for a long time, with good reason. Thank you so much for the review. :)
So that was the shot heard 'round the world? Nice. I like it. It made me smile.
FYI, I noticed one error - when he's talking about placing the commander under the Imperious Curse, it should be "we'll just Imperuse the regulars' commander."
Wow! Just wow!
Your writing is nice and descriptive. I like that not only did you care about the story, but about how you told the story.
You captured Draco's perspective very well, and Luna singing on Christmas Eve was so in-character, I'm surprised it wasn't in the book.
What a fantastic story. I hope to see more soon. =)
Also, the part of me that loves non-canon romance wants to see you write a Luna/Draco ;)
Author's Response: Aw, thanks for the review. I'm glad you like the story so far. Hopefully I'll be getting out other chapters soon. Lol, while I was writing this I could also picture a Luna/Draco romance, but, unfortunately, that won't be where I take this. Maybe another time :)
Hi. I noticed that you still don't have any reviews, even after posting five chapters. I'd like to commend you for your perseverance. It's not easy to keep writing without getting any feedback.
There were a few elements of your story that I really liked. It was interesting to me that you made Lily afraid. I'm now interested to see why she's put into Gryffindor.
You also have some good dialog. I loved the line "What in the world is a Peeves?" Quite funny.
Now, there were a couple small details I'd like to address.
1. Julianna is not a very popular name. It is getting more popular, but it is still only the 147th most popular name (yeah, I looked it up...). You sort of addressed this by having Lily think it was unusual. However, it is about ten times as popular now as it was in 1960, when Lily and her classmates were born. So it would have been very unlikely for a Muggle baby to be given that name. Wizarding names tend to be old-fashioned (case in point: Neville), making it even more unlikely for Julianna to have her name. For future original characters, I would recommend looking up baby names from the year your character was born. Choosing a time-period appropriate name is a nice way of telling your readers, "Hey, I put a lot of effort into this story."
2. It bugged me a little bit that Lily hoped James and Sirius went to Slytherin without knowing what Slytherin was. Better to have her get something wrong about the wizarding world in her mutterings. Like she hopes they grow warts everywhere or turn green. I don't know, something besides going to Slytherin.
3. I didn't realize it until just now, but where is Snape? They were childhood friends, and he told her quite a bit about the wizarding world. No wonder this seems off to me. If they aren't friends in your story, you should probably list this as AU.
You're doing pretty well with your dialog and descriptions. Just watch out for the details. Good luck. Keep writing.
Author's Response: 1) I hope to address Julianna's unusual name in the future, but I do realize it's not very common. I have tried to make all my other OC's have much more common names, though.
2) I do agree with this and I have switched this.
3) I've never been very fond of Snape, at least not while he attended Hogwarts. I'm still coming to terms with him at the end of DH. But in my end notes I clarified that Lily not knowing him is the only non-canon element to their relationship. She is friends with him later.
I hope this cleared things up!
I love how unexpected and unique this story is. You took all the cliches of Marauder Era and turned them on their heads. I look forward to the next chapter.
Author's Response: Thank you! :) I hope the next chapters will live up to expectations. - Natalie
Nominated for a 2014 and a 2015 QSQ - Best Dark/Angst.
I am incredibly pleased to announce that this story WON Best Dark/Angst in the 2015 QSQs!!!!! :D :D :DWhat a fascinating look at the tragic tale of Merope Gaunt.
I especially like your title (I had to look up the definition) and the stars motif. It was very poetically written, and I think you handled sensitive topics well.
Well this is the most unique story I've read in a long time, for several reasons: 1. Hermione/Fred is a rarepair. 2. There are quite a few fics out there in which there isn't an immediate happily ever after following the Battle of Hogwarts. Basically none of them have an adventure for Hermione. It's always something that happens to Harry or Ron.
I really liked how original it was. I like being surprised, and you did that here.
It also did a good job of pulling on my emotions. My favorite part was:
“When will she be coming home?†croaked a voice from the corner. Everyone turned to look at Fred who hadn’t spoken a word since dinner.
Hermione was silent. Oh, she wanted to tell Fred that she was home!"
Great job! I will definitely be following this story.
Author's Response: Thank you! I appreciate the reviews. I promise I will update as soon as possible. The idea for this story just kinda sprang itself on me and I had to write it. I love Fremione (though it is not my OTP), and was very sad to find that there were little to no Fremione fics on this site. Which is weird considering it was almost canon.
Ahhh! The suspense is killing me. What is this prophecy! I can't wait for your next chapter. (Which is exactly what should happen with a good story like this. Great job!)
First and foremost, I love how unique this story is. It is funny and heartwarming at the same time, which is an excellent combination.
It makes me laugh to see the gang as senior citizens. I like that you portrayed them as having lived long, full, happy lives. (As opposed to them being crotchety and cranky.)
With your interviews, it would have been nice to have you switch fonts or something when more than one person is being interviewed. It's not terribly confusing, but it would be an easier read if that was clear.
I had a great time reading this story.
Author's Response:
Thanks for the review.The gang are all approaching sixty, and they would take exception to being called senior citizens (one in particular).
There was only one “shared interviewâ€, and I tried to make it clear who was talking.-N-
Sorry I said your characters were senior citizens. I must have misread their ages.
To Lavender: Dearie, I wasn't referring to you. I was shocked to hear you are a grandmother. You look more like Harry's daughter-in-law than his classmate. You have aged incredibly well.
Author's Response: :-D
Thanks for making me smile.
-N-
I like this quite a bit. I'm impressed with your rapid turnaround after the article. This is such a fun little piece. I love your characterization of Victoire.
Author's Response: Thank you very much! :D Victoire was really fun to write; her character came through strongly in the gifset, even with just a few lines of dialogue, and it was easy for me to pick it up and run with it. I was surprised with myself at how quickly I was able to write the story (in the space of an afternoon, the day after I first saw the gifs) but again, it was just easy to run with. :) And it's just a short thing. I'm so glad you liked it!
As usual, I love reading your work. This one is intriguing. I find it interesting that Scorpius is on such good terms with so many of the teachers. He tends to suck up a bit, but nothing like his father. It seems as if he doesn't have many friends his age (otherwise he would have had the package delivered to a friend.)
I look forward to reading the next chapter.
Author's Response: Thank you so much, Sydney, for reading my story and leaving a review. I have modeled Scorpius on a few young men I have known in my life who seemed to have poise beyond their years and interacted easily and comfortably with people of all ages. Old ladies loved them. One of them was going to become a doctor, and I'm sure he ended up having a fabulous bedside manner.
I see Scorpius as being on a continuum of decency, starting with his grandfather Lucius, who did a bunch of bad things, then continuing through his father Draco, who had some personality flaws as a boy but was mainly the victim of terrible circumstances, and ending with Scorpius, who's a pretty nice guy, although you can see the family influence. He has learned to be a keen observer and judge of himself and others, he knows how to structure relationships to further his own interest, he has a certain sense of entitlement...As my beta Elaine says, he has no problems with self-esteem! He had a special reason for having the package go straight to Professor Longbottom; you will see this in the next chapter.
The more I read, the more I like Scorpius. I like the path the Malfoy family is taking, the continuum of decency, like you said.
You really understand people, and that is very apparent in this story. Your characterization is fantastic. And even though this is not exactly a fast-paced or suspenseful story in the traditional sense, I still find myself excited for the next chapter. Very well done, Vicki.
Author's Response: Thank you for approving of my characterization. I find it enjoyable to deal with original characters or characters not well characterized in canon, because it is very creative to build their character, bit by bit. You will enjoy the next chapter, I think.
This is a fun read. Its a neat idea and well written. I like that Gulka invented indoor plumbing, and the part about the genius squirrels. The only improvement I can think of would be to expand it a bit, mainly the second-to-last paragraph. Having a few more detailed strange tales about the tree would make it more like an old legend.
Author's Response: Thank you for taking the time. I am glad and very grateful for the positive feedback. I still feel that the writing style of the first few paragraphs is too dense and convoluted.
There is a certain whimsy and dark humour to Harry Potter that I have always admired and attempted to emulate in this story. The original plan called for a story at least three-times this length with further examples of the Tree's destructive influence over the years and then a lengthy explanation of what exactly happened when Voldemort reaches the Tree, including what I imagine the process of creating a horcrux to be. Ultimately I decided against it and cut vast parts out in an effort to maintain the tone I had struck at the beginning.
I am hugely flattered that your only suggestion is to ask for more of the same. Thank you again.
Well this is incredibly unique. Great job coming up with a new angle.
I have a feeling I am going to love seeing the interactions between wizards and muggles.
I like that you already have an obvious conflict. That gets the reader immediately involved. However, just basically saying, "I don't know how the conflict took a bad turn," is a cheap way to do it. You handled it well, though, by having the characters stop eachother from explaining because of the importance of timing.
Overall, well done. I look forward to reading more.