I really like this story. The characters are very 'in character' yet seen from a different perspective, and the descriptions are very creative and clever. There is some excellent imagery in here.
LOL!!! Oh how funny, and making mention of "The Unseemly Proposal", how hilarious is that?!
I love it! Wish there was more to read, but a wonderfully hilarious story non-the-less.
Having read through the first three chapters, I must say that I really do enjoy this story. I had my doubts about it, but it seems to be a wonderful set up so far. Plus, I just had to say that I'm still laughing over Draco bursting into Hermione's room 'just making sure that your room was not bigger than mine.' That is hilarious! That whole scene, with the nightgown and all, was excellent! Good job!
And no, contrary to beliefs very likely impressed upon you by this summary, I'm not a gormless prat.
Well... not entirely.
Another brilliant chapter. I'm gettin repititious, I know, but it's true! What a fascinating plot twist, making Tia have to tutor Lily and vice-versa.
Your situations are totally belivable and your characterization is fascinating. You imagery and dialogue are....hmm, what other adjectives can I use? I must go look up some new ones so that I can use them to gush over the next chapter, which, I'm sure, will be equally spectacular.
I love it! The boys protecting Tia's honour. What girl doesn't love that thought?
Again, nothing to complain about and everything to gush about. I love how the romance between Sirius and Tia is developing achingly slowly. I'm half-dying over here, begging them to get together already! You've done a great job of creating the tension for the reader.
I think this has to be my favourite story that I've read yet on this site, and I'm hard pressed to imagine a story that could top it.
I love it! The boys protecting Tia's honour. What girl doesn't love that thought?
Again, nothing to complain about and everything to gush about. I love how the romance between Sirius and Tia is developing achingly slowly. I'm half-dying over here, begging them to get together already! You've done a great job of creating the tension for the reader.
I think this has to be my favourite story that I've read yet on this site, and I'm hard pressed to imagine a story that could top it.
I really do enjoy reading this story, although, this chapter wasn't formatted properly, I think, and therefore it is one long paragraph. I still enjoyed it, however. I like how the relationship between Tia and Sirius is very slow to evolve. It's very realistic.
The note banter was great, as per usual. I really don't know how much more I can gush over this story. I'm sure it must be getting old by now.
No complaints, loved it all. How true is it that a woman is sometimes so agitated, yet can't quite pinpoint why? I don't know about the rest of the women in the world, but I do it! I love that Tia gets that problem too.
Pointless fluff?! (referring to your A/N) How could you call this pointless fluff? This was brilliant. Not only is it funny, but the writing is excellent, the characterization is excellent, and so is the imagery. I really enjoyed reading this. My favorite line has to be: “Don’t be silly. It was going spiffingly–up ‘til the point Prongs hit puberty.”
I had to lay my head on my desk and laugh after reading that!
Can't wait to read more and it's only the first chapter. I'm hooked!
Again, another excellent chapter. I think the last line has got to be my favorite. It was clear I needed a new death glare–this one was losing its potency.
There are so many lines and words in here that I find so highly amusing that I want to add them to my own daily usage. You have done a spectacularly sarcastic job with this story. I love it.
In all of this wonderful writing, I think this may be one of the very few mistakes that I found: And of course there were the other array of faint scars he sported all over his body in various places that I’d had glimpses of over the years
I have not had a chance to finish your story, but I have enjoyed it already. Very fascinating characterization. I also really like your descriptions and the way you bring Blaise to life. Very, very fascinating tale. I can't wait to finish your one-shot .
Author's Response: Thanks!
Oh no! Ginny has found her in an emergency situation of dire need. Harry lies before her and Ron and Hermione are long gone. Whatever shall she do? Well, it looks like Ginny is feeling a bit Dramatic.
Okay, let me stop laughing first!
You are so funny!! I loved this. Everyone giving Ginny tea! I fully expected her to say something about having to pee at some point. I love the part abour her having to check the rating before what she said, and Draco being evil-in-training!
The whole thing was brilliant, I shouldn't list the parts I liked best because I'd just end up re-writing the whole story, and, well, you already know it!!
Great job!! (As per usual!)
Author's Response:
=) Yay! Thanking ye kindly. Your reviews always make me happy.
I really enjoyed this story. The part with Ron being a complete idiot while drunk was too funny. It probably would be pretty accurate, too, I bet.
I would have liked to have read the next morning scene where Ron and Harry wake up next to each other. There would have been a lot of funny potential in that scene!
Good story! Very amusing.
Where in the world do you come up with this stuff?! A half-starved monkey?! Priceless
I loved: the cunning Mr. Malfoy pulled a quill and parchment from the bag of a small Ravenclaw girl at the next table. How very much like Draco. I loved his extremely over-inflated ego also. Try to veer away from using words like ‘yucky’ and ‘gross’. Perhaps consider ‘density’, or ‘dim-witted’ or even such phrases as ‘lack of wit or mental ability’ instead. I would like to suggest adding in how very ugly James Potter was and the disadvantages of the ‘Potter gene’ That could keep a person laughing for weeks!!
Another awesome one-shot!
signed,
Your admirer when it comes to writing humour fics, because she's desperately awful at it,
-Erica
(Well that, and you're a really great writer in dark fiction, too boot!)
My most favorite part of all would have to be Snape's comments on the back of the parchment!
Author's Response:
Aww - thank you! Young!Draco was a whole lot of fun to write. He\'s got very few inhibitions and a highly respectable (/particularly frightening and rightly so) father, so he also has very few limits. Which means - yeah, fun!
Thank you for heading over to this little story, and I\'m very happy to hear that you liked it!
Hmm, not quite sure how, but my review wasn't posted correctly. The very last line, the comment about Snape's part being my most favorite, should have gone just before the beginning of my quotes from his comments.
Hmm, does that make sense?
Well, sorry, anyway. Just wanted to clarify.
Author's Response:
Wow. I have absolutely, positively no idea how that might have happened. Ah, the joys of strange review function... uh, side-effects. O_O
Who would have thought of making Cher a Witch? I love it! What a fascinating way to tie it into the real or 'Muggle' world. I enjoyed the chapter, and the mystery of it. Very nice writing style.
Author's Response: Thank you! I thought it fit nicely! I\'m glad to see you found your way over to my side of the Forbidden Forest!
Wow! It is clearly evident that a lot of hard work and thought went into this chapter. I get the feeling that you have this story planned out very well. Very fascinating chapter.
Author's Response: Thank you so much!
A very fascinating little story here! I like your writing style and your story telling. You said you were taking the story in the direction of your theories. I heartily agree with what you have come up with.
Excellent story.
What a deeply stirring and beautiful story. It was passionate and painful all at the same time. You have captured the emotions perfectly. A truly beautiful story. Thank you for sharing it.
Author's Response: Oh god, I owe you two huge thanks at once really. One is just for reading this story. This is the single story I am most proud of. It\'s by far not my most popular story, but it is my favorite. So just for reading and reviewing thank you so much. But also for the second nomination, I truly appreciate that as well. I could seriously talk about this story for ages, where it came from, why I wrote it, why I did things in it the way I did, but really, the simple thing about this, the reason why I think it\'s connects with people is because It\'s me. I\'m not on my deathbed, but this is what was going through my head when one day I foundmyself having to say goodbye to my two daughters. So yeah, it gets rough. Anyway thanks so much for both the review and the nod, and I hope you\'ll come back around and checkthe rest of my stories, all of which in the same storyline as this, although much much earlier.